Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Nats win. Bregman approaching his ABs like he has been Matt Carpenterized. Definitely not the stuff of an MVP.
This is being talked about now on the WS game on TV. Evidently Cooper had knee surgery after working the Yanks/Twins ALDS. He was recuperating at his father’s home and had a blood clot, which was the cause.
October 21, 2019 at 11:46 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2019-2020 #112393It’s only appropriate that Big Sexy generates the first blast of heat for this year’s hot stove. If he can land a game in 2020, his career will have touched four different decades.
I always got a kick out of watching him bat — not because he was comically bad at hitting, but because evidently there is no helmet size or style that fits properly on his head.
The problem with MadBum is some team will probably pay him like he’s still an elite pitcher. A lot of risk goes to whoever wins the MadBum sweepstakes.
Getting cut on is definitely a risk, but the probability must’ve been low for Martinez to return to where he needs to be physically without the procedure.
Seriously, having Fowler and Ozuna in the same outfield is really tough on the eyes.
There’s a reason the Cards got better this year. It’s not a popular approach, but defense matters. Up the middle and 1B got much better in 2019, now tighten it up in the corners.
Not sure Rat, but hope they cleaned up the “right” shoulder, as the vis aids suggest.
The hitting approach is bad, and most of them don’t adjust based on the situation (e.g., 2 strikes, just need to make contact with a runner on 3B and one out, off-speed pitcher vs power pitcher, etc.)
A different and bigger problem than “hitting approach” might be that so many of the Cards have poor pitch recognition. Pitch recognition is a talent that isn’t easily taught if a player doesn’t have it. This leads to bad swings and misses on pitches way out of the zone. The difference between very good and bad pitch recognition is a very small slice of time.
The poor pitch recognition problem can be mitigated somewhat with a better hitting approach, e.g., when a situation calls for it such as 2 strikes, don’t be afraid to let the pitch get deeper while loading for the swing.
Baseball analytics sort of reminds me of stock market technical analysis — they’ve become self fulfilling prophecies in some ways. Sure, the stock market goes down when certain technical factors are in play because most investors are conditioned to sell off because they are fearing the now inevitable drop that the technical factors suggest. They disregard a stock’s positive fundamental factors. Likewise, you’re probably not going to succeed with today’s players suddenly using previous hitting approaches found in terms like shortening up with 2 strikes, just make contact, small ball, etc. That’s because so few believe in it, practice it, and most importantly, they aren’t any good at it these days.
October 16, 2019 at 12:11 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2019-2020 #111925At times, Carp’s had decent numbers at 3B. The same can’t be said for OF. If we learned anything this year, Edman plays multiple positions. Keeping both Carp and Edman in the lineup doesn’t mean Edman has to be at 3B. Edman played the super utility role quite well and may continue providing that flexibility next year. Just because Ozuna is awful in the OF doesn’t mean the Cards should replace him with another awful defender, if in fact Ozuna leaves. It’s a loser’s approach.
October 16, 2019 at 11:23 am in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2019-2020 #111921mudville, you’re not the only person I’ve heard say that — stopped trying. I’m interested in why you say that. I look at Carp as a guy who’s just not that good any more. He’s been in massive decline for 14 months now. I always thought he was a grinder with a lot of pride. That’s why I cringed in Game 4 against Atl when the crowd gave him a sarcastically loud booing when he fielded Swanson’s foul ball in the 8th. And I’m a guy who was not a fan of Carp in the lineup most of this year.
I do believe the psychological aspects of sports are vastly underrated and often not acknowledged like they should be. That’s probably because intangibles are not well understood and hard to prove. So I do believe the contract could have an impact, but don’t perceive the stopped trying part. Admittedly, I only know what I read and see on TV.
October 16, 2019 at 10:46 am in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2019-2020 #111916Carp in the outfield is a terrible idea. It’ll make putting Matt Adams out there look smart. They tried it early in his career and it was a bad fit. And that was back when he was faster, quicker, and had less launch angle on his throws when he lobbed his moon shots. Plus his natural defensive instincts seem low to me, and that’s in positions where he’s had a lot of innings.
Good luck getting a good free agent pitcher if this gains traction. Even the remote possibility of an occasional OF lineup of Carp, Fowler, JMart would cause most pitchers’ heads to spin.
This is clearly a case of a terrible decision (Carp extension) leading to subsequent bad ideas.
Just an embarrassing series for the Cards. They were emasculated. With the bases loaded and two outs, and amazingly they have a chance, they send up Matt Carpenter as the go-ahead run. Instead of effing them up, that’s how you eff yourself up. Also, somebody wake up Goldy and let him know the LCS has started and finished.
I saw a statistical analysis a few years ago of winning a series when down 0-3. It has rarely happened in history, 3% I think I read. Were the Red Sox the only team to do it?
Anyway, if the two teams are even, then there is a 6.25% (.0625 probability) chance the trailing team will win four in a row (the math is 0.5 to the 4th power). It further stated that assume the team trailing is inferior and give them just a 0.45 probability of winning an individual game. Then the probability of coming back to win the series is 4.1% (0.45 to the 4th power). That’s pretty low, but higher than the historical rate.
Therefore, the analysis speculated we should see more comebacks in the future from 0-3 deficits, i.e., return to the mean. In case you don’t know, return or regression to the means says data points will randomly occur above and below the mean, and over time, this distribution will even out. Ha! The Cards have the Nats right where they want them.
We also see Shildt does in fact have a limit on loyalty, and Fowler is not leading off. So there’s that going for the Cards, too. It’s sometimes better to arrive late to the party rather than not at all.
It’s rough willie, you’re taking one for the team! I decided to change channels and watch the Packers. If Shildt thinks he was drawing criticism from the press prior to this game, he’s going to love it afterwards. If Fowler is leading off again tomorrow, I’m not going to bother with it.
Jack’s about done. No way this one is going back to St L. Cards haven’t done much of anything since Atlanta. I guess the F-Bomb speech didn’t work.
Total meltdown by the Cards in the 3rd. Wake up Molina.
The lack of support, at the plate and in the field, has killed Flaherty. The 3rd inning has been brutal for him and the Cards chances. You just can’t be perfect no matter how good you are. He won’t be going 7 tonight.
Outfield defense kills the Cards. Gold glove Ozuna is plain bad out there.
Nats to get Flaherty in the 3rd, scoring the first on a single by Eaton to drive in Robles. That doesn’t do much for the Cards’ win probability with the offense still stuck in reverse.
DeJong actually had a good, professional AB. Fowler on the other hand has looked pathetic both times. No one would’ve expected that — great call, Shildt.
Ozuna erases his nice double with mindless base running. Other than, it’s the usual — no life at the plate. Scoring a run off Strasburg looks next to impossible tonight. Maybe Jack can throw 7 shutout innings and make it a pen game. Seems to be the path to victory if there is one.
The lineup needed an infusion of energy, but I would’ve done something at the top of the order. Expecting Fowler to do anything now seems out of touch with the reality of the last several weeks. I would’ve had Edman at the top. But obviously Shildt’s willing to go down with whatever tone Fowler can set.
Game over. The hill to climb is really steep now. Hitters need to step it up. For that matter, Shildt needs to raise his game a lot too. Martinez seems to be making all the right moves and Shildt has missed a couple.
Helsley has had a helluva postseason.
Sounds good to me GACard. Need to put Carp back in a pinch hitter role and get Fowler out of the lead off spot. Need Edman at or near the top of the order. If not Aroz, I’d go back to Bader, he hit the ball hard twice in Game 5 in Atlanta. Some infusion of energy is needed to set a different tone. Shildt shouldn’t sleep on it any longer.
-
AuthorPosts
