forsch31

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 25 posts - 2,451 through 2,475 (of 2,639 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Percent Who Make It By Level #38971
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    Cardinals2016

    Participant

    @forsch, I said something about the if the Cardinals can’t draft a star in the draft, they either have to trade for them (giving up multiple players) or overpay in free agency.

    You asked when there has ever been a star available in the last 7-8 years when the Cardinals drafted.

    I gave you two examples off the top of my head.

    This is your first error. At the time they were drafted, those players were not known to be stars. They don’t fit what I am asking. Someone like a JD Drew would be close but he never lived up to the hype. No team drafts someone outside of the top 15 players in the draft and EXPECTS them to be a star. They HOPE they will become one.

    Maybe part of my problem is that I misunderstood what you were saying. Maybe you weren’t putting down the Cardinals for not drafting a star player. However, if you weren’t, I don’t think you would have said “the Cardinals don’t know how”, you would have said “the Cardinals have been unable to”.

    You then said nobody ever criticized those moves at the time.

    I gave you examples from the 2016 draft and indicated that was my first year on the board.

    I don’t know whether you commented before the draft – I started my thread after the draft, criticizing the Carlson pick, because it seems like a move where the Cardinals are trying to prove they are smarter than EVERYBODY in baseball, but the reality is it looks like a subpar pick. EVERYBODY on this board attacked me on that thread for voicing my opinions and backing it up with statistical evidence. But I knew that would happen when I created the thread, and did it anyway.

    If I would have said much of anything, it would have been to point out that sometimes picks like Carlson are made to allow us to draft other players that we wouldn’t have a chance to pick otherwise. As was pointed out by Noonan and others at times, we can draft players like Hudson because of underslot signings. You may have been sure that Solak and Neuse would have signed for below slot, but maybe the Cardinals did their due diligence and thought they couldn’t save enough bonus money by drafting one of them. Neither of us know for sure.

    There is strong statistical evidence that the higher the pick, the more likely they are to reach the majors (thus, you should make SURE your first round picks hit). There is strong statistical evidence college picks outperform high school picks on average. There is also statistical evidence that you are more likely to draft superstars from the high school ranks, which is why teams ignore the statistical evidence that college players are better on average.

    The way the draft bonus pools are constructed, teams make less than optimal choices. That leads to trying to game the system. That was the Carlson pick. Everybody defended the move as he signed below slot. I pointed out better players who likely would have signed below slot. Nick Solak was projected for the back of the second round, he went in the back of the second round. He is now the 5th best 2B prospect in baseball.

    No, I am not saying Solak, Bichette and Neuse are stars. They haven’t made it to the majors yet. Indications are, they are going to be at least above average players. I mean, Solak & Bichette are rated in the Top 5 at their positions among prospects.

    I think I covered this.

    1. But basically, what you are saying – anybody that expresses an opinion that does not 100% agree with what the Cardinals do – you are going to attack.
    2. And when your arguments are confronted with facts, you will attack them in a new way.
    3. And when those are rebutted with facts, you will say that is not what you meant.
    4. If somebody doesn’t express an opinion at the time something happens, nobody can claim they knew better. But if they do express an opinion at the time, they can’t foretell the future so they must be attacked.

    Glad we are clear.

    1. No. They will make mistakes and I don’t always agree with their decisions. As a matter of fact, I thought the Leake and Fowler signings were for too long and I expressed those opinions at the time. But I notice that while you feel you can question the Cardinals, you also feel that I can’t question your opinion.
    2. I still haven’t changed my position or seen any “facts” from you that addressed that position.
    3. And I still haven’t seen any “facts” that rebuts my position.
    4. If you feel I am “attacking”, you need to rethink being on a message board.

    BTW, let me know how your scouting gig turns out.

    in reply to: Giancarlo Stanton thread #38959
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    Onyx, you are correct. I am taking my reply to a different thread for those who don’t care to participate or read through.

    As far as Stanton goes, I hope we hear something in the next week. As long as we don’t give up too much, I think he propels us to at least the playoffs. With a couple of reliever acquisitions and some growth by our rotation, we could be a World Series contender. We should also have room to make more moves to step up to the Cubs level for several years to come.

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #38905
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    Do you think Cozart would sign here if he thought he wouldn’t be the starting SS after 2018 or that he would have to share the starting duties with DeJong and Garcia. If you include 3B in the mix, there are 486 possible starts for 5 players and that doesn’t include Carpenter. If you only give Garcia 50 starts, that leaves around 110 starts apiece for the other 4.

    Is Cozart’s defense, at this time, good enough to justify him starting over DeJong if Cozart reverts back to his pre-2017 batting? DeJong played slightly above average defense from what I can recall the experts saying.

    I agree that the Cardinals don’t have enough depth at SS but I don’t think Cozart with his salary is the answer. Either you acquire an elite defender or go with DeJong.

    in reply to: Giancarlo Stanton thread #38904
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    BTW, you said I participated in the 2016 draft thread. Do you remember anyone that I proposed that the Cardinals should draft?

    in reply to: Giancarlo Stanton thread #38903
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    C2016, I have not changed my argument. You have misinterpreted what I said. You were the one who brought up Stanton and Arenado (2nd rounders) as 2 players that fit the mold of a “known star at the time they were drafted”. I merely pointed out that for being a know star, 29 other teams passed on them at least 1 time.

    So you are saying that Bichette, Welker, Neuse and Solak are known stars? By whose definition?

    I never knocked your acquisition of Welker whenever you suggested it unless I felt you were trying to give up too much to get him. However, I don’t think I made a comment on it at all.

    Also, I don’t usually comment on the draft threads because I don’t know enough about all the prospects. I will comment on posters basically acting like they are a scout or a GM and who knock the team just because they don’t like who they drafted. You don’t know who will be a star in the majors at the time someone is drafted. If you did, Pujols wouldn’t have been drafted in the 13th round.

    in reply to: Giancarlo Stanton thread #38899
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    I have a feeling the Dodgers have basically said to the Marlins that they don’t want to trade for Stanton unless the Marlins take on some salary back for 2018. Whether that be through Marlins paying some of Stanton’s salary or taking some high salary player from the Dodgers (Puig, Kazmir, Gonzalez) If this happened after 2018, I think the Dodgers would be all over Stanton and take on the whole salary without stipulations.

    in reply to: Giancarlo Stanton thread #38888
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    Well, since Arenado and Stanton were drafted in the 2nd round, that means at least 29 teams didn’t realize they were going to be star position players. Kind of hard to blame the Cardinals for that.

    There were 75 players drafted ahead of Stanton and I don’t recall anyone saying the Cardinals should have drafted him in that draft. 58 players were drafted of Arenado and I don’t recall anyone saying we should have drafted him instead of Shelby Miller.

    Almost every draft would have been drafted differently if a team could see into the future to see what a player would become 8-10 years after being drafted. Any star player drafted after the first 15 picks is more luck than skill.

    Who did the Cardinals have to trade for Ozuna?

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #38880
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    I keep seeing on these topics how signing Cozart and moving DeJong to a utility role is good. I am not understanding how Cozart’s 1 season with an OPS above .769, at almost age 32, makes him more valuable than DeJong. Someone please explain it to me.

    in reply to: Giancarlo Stanton thread #38878
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    Cardinals2016

    Participant

    Too often, people applaud management for their fiscal conservatism rather than their attempts to put a championship team on the field.

    1. If the Cardinals don’t know how to draft for star position players, they have to either trade for them or overpay in free agency.

    2. If you trade for them, you have to give up more than one prospect at a time, that’s the market now.

    1. Do you know which player will be a star position player? Has any “known” star position player been available to the Cardinals to draft at the positions they have drafted over the last 7-8 years?

    2. How many quality prospects were available for the Cardinals to trade before the 2017 season? Who were they?

    in reply to: Giancarlo Stanton thread #38805
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    I am hoping he opts out and I think there is a good chance that he will.

    in reply to: Giancarlo Stanton thread #38803
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    If DeWitt was so concerned, he wouldn’t have given his OK for a trade proposal. To me, it appears that saying he PREFERS to come in second is a slam against DeWitt. If you are saying that he would accept coming in second due to the risk, that is something totally different, IMO.

    I am sure there is some concern since no one can predict what will happen in the future. The longer a contract goes, the greater the financial risk, obviously.

    My comments come from reading many posters on here over the years slamming DeWitt for not signing players. How many of those big free agent signings have really paid off?

    in reply to: Giancarlo Stanton thread #38801
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    DeWitt has owned the Cardinals for 22 full seasons. In that time, the Cardinals have had 3 seasons with losing records. They have been to the playoffs 13 times. Been to the World Series 4 times with 2 wins in the World Series. They have consistently been in the top half of the payrolls in the league despite being in what is considered a small market. Yet, FANS of the Cardinals still believe that he doesn’t want to win or is cheap. Amazing.

    I hope the Giants upping their offer helps Stanton decide to come to St. Louis. I can’t see how trading away the future from a team that hasn’t been very good for the last year and a half would make them a desired destination for someone who wants to win.

    in reply to: Miles Mikolas #38798
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    I am willing to give him a pass on his previous stint in MLB. He made it to the majors before his 24th birthday and struggled. He went over to Japan before he turned 27 and lowered his walks and allowed less hits/9 innings. He obviously must have something given a quick look at everything.

    If nothing else, it gives us some starter depth.

    in reply to: Giancarlo Stanton thread #38737
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    Cardinals2016

    Participant

    Well, this is new:

    “Report: Marlins interested in Cardinals’ Michael Wacha, Jose Martinez in Stanton trade talks. https://thesco.re/2jMIMG9 ”

    I would give up those 2 for Stanton and pay all Stanton’s salary. However, we would have to sign probably 2 free agent SPs to do it. Wainwright, Weaver and Martinez are the only proven starters if they trade Wacha. We don’t know if Reyes is ready to start and Flaherty looked like he needed some more time in AAA.

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #38735
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    I would be on board to acquire Welker.

    in reply to: Cards Trade Diaz #38732
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    A point to consider: when is a player’s high point? Diaz showed promise in 2016 that more could be coming. It didn’t, he lost his value and DeJong took his spot. Also, at the beginning of the 2017 season, there appeared to be no one to play SS if the Cardinals traded Diaz.

    We can revise history all we want. If Diaz had been traded prior to 2017, the fan forums would have been calling for wholesale changes in Cardinals management.

    in reply to: Giancarlo Stanton thread #38494
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    I think it was Jim Bowden that gave another opinion about the Stanton deal. He believes the Cardinals offered the best deal to the Marlins but he thinks the Marlins feel they are more likely to get him to say yes to being traded to the Giants.

    in reply to: Giancarlo Stanton thread #38450
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    One thing I think some are forgetting is that Mo/Girsch can’t talk to Stanton about why he should come to St. Louis without an OK from the Marlins and league. He is not a free agent.

    I am sure the Cardinals have tried to negotiate to a point that is favorable to the Cardinals and their future. I am sure they probably would go further than they already have but why give your absolute best offer right from the start. The Cardinals could always jump back into the mix.

    I think if he goes to the Giants, it is because he wants to be on the West Coast. It certainly won’t be because the Giants can win it all in the next 2 years.

    in reply to: Giancarlo Stanton thread #38303
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    Brian Walton

    Keymaster

    Morosi provides more details.

    “Giancarlo Stanton trade is not imminent, sources say. While his camp has given #Marlins a list of acceptable teams, indications are the group may be negotiable. Thus, the free-agent logjam persists.”

    I would think that some of the negotiation on Stanton’s behalf would depend on the trade details and how that affects the teams involved. In other words, if the team trading for him gives up so much that they are a marginal playoff team for the next few years, how does that help him decide to go there. Also, if that team restocks the Marlins and they now become a formidable opponent, he has another obstacle to win a WS. It is in his best interest to be traded for the smallest package possible. Although, he MAY feel an obligation to make sure the Marlins are in a good place for the future.

    in reply to: Logan Morrison free agent thread #37967
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    Nate, here is the definition of troll according to Merriam-Webster online dictionary:

    to harass, criticize, or antagonize (someone) especially by provocatively disparaging or mocking public statements, postings, or acts.

    It sure looks to me that a majority of your posts fall under that definition.

    I am glad you included some ideas in your post but you know they are unrealistic for any team. The payroll that it would take to field your team would be the highest ever seen and impossible. Also, there is no baseball organization that would have the trade chips to complete all those trades and still be competitive. While it would be nice to trade for Stanton and Votto, and then sign Arrieta or Darvish and Davis, it’s not going to happen. Why don’t we just speak in reality about something constructive.

    Now, back to Morrison.

    in reply to: Logan Morrison free agent thread #37914
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    Nate, I see you have come back to troll some more. I hope one of these days you stop with the drive-by diatribes about how the front office will do nothing. Why not give a constructive opinion on what the should do or state an opinion on why they should not do something?

    As for Morrison, if he has finally found the potential that he once showed, he could be of help but I don’t see how he improves our team much more than what we already have. Maybe by having Carpenter as the super sub, there is an improvement. One thing that Morrison does bring is a LH bat.

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #37558
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    Fair enough. I wonder why they average Heyward’s bonus over the first 3 years of the contract but list Lester’s remaining $15 million over the next 3 years despite it being years 4, 5 and 6 of his contract?

    I still stick to the point that this proposed trade will hurt the Cubs in the intermediate to long run. They will be getting into salary restrictions unless they are willing to push their payroll to very high levels.

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #37509
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    Pads, Cots has the Cubs at $137 million estimated for 2018 and Baseball Reference has them at $132 million estimated for 2018. So if you add $62 million to the lower of the 2, you get to $194 million for 2018. They will also have a lot of arbitration raises after 2018.

    This would also give the Cubs a starting rotation ages of 34, 33, 32, 29 and 28 on opening day 2018 with very little in the form of quality prospects in the minors. I see trouble down the road unless they eat some salaries in a couple of years.

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #37488
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    I think I would like to see the Cubs do that trade. That strengthens their pitching but weakens their OF. It also adds salary to them. If they re-sign Arrieta and sign Martinez, they will be a beast for 2018 but will be getting close to being financially handcuffed for the future years. All those moves would put them close to $200 million in salary in 2018. After 2018, they have arbitration raises for Bryant, Hendricks, Russell, Schwarber, Baez and Montgomery while only having Rondon and Justin Wilson as possible FAs.

    The Cardinals would definitely be able to counter with some moves but they have to be willing to make them. The acquisition of Stanton would have to be done.

    in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #37139
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    CC, I actually proposed using Lyons as a starter in 2018 back on September 20th. I had proposed the following trade:

    forsch31

    Participant

    Trade CMart, Kelly, Gyorko and Grichuk/Piscotty for Freddie Freeman, Markakis, Mike Soroka and Kolby Allard. We may need to throw in a prospect, as well. We would have to use Lyons as a starter and we might be a little thin at starting pitcher until Reyes is ready to start again. We would be in great shape for the next 4 years. We would shift Carp back to 3B with Diaz or Wisdom to back him up.

    This would be a case of giving up something valuable today for something needed today and set us up for the future. Soroka is a RH starter ranked #48 by BA, #64 by BP and #78 by MLB at the beginning of the season. He is up to #34 by MLB. Allard is a LH starter ranked #37 by BA, #53 by MLB and #67 by BP at the beginning of the season. He is up to #21 by MLB.

    High cost by Atlanta but they solve 2 immediate needs of TOR pitcher and their C for the next 10 years. We also shore up their need for a stopgap 3B until Kevin Maitan and Austin Riley are ready. They are VERY deep in SP prospects.

    Looking back on it, I would probably also re-sign Lynn and let Flaherty get some more time in AAA.

Viewing 25 posts - 2,451 through 2,475 (of 2,639 total)

First-hand news and commentary on the St. Louis Cardinals™ and minor league system for over 25 years