Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
I’m not certain how much credibility it had, but I read an article not too long ago that claimed Edman indeed had enough innings in ’22 at the SS position to qualify for a GG award at SS.
The rule is you’re eligible for just one position. That’s the one where you played the most innings, as long as it meets the minimum number. You must have 698 total innings by the 138th game. Of course Edman had that many. So SS it is for Edman. How the new utility gold glove plays into this, I’m not sure. Haven’t been able to find those criteria.
(Wow, I need to read these posts more thoroughly and quicker. I just noticed 25s post where he said this first.)
LOL, forsch. Correct. I was just playing with/poking at 25 on that. For the record, I don’t think there’s any moral high ground for either opinion here.
I would guess he would be ineligible for either individual position.
No. You’re eligible for the position where you played the MOST innings. SS for Edman.
My comment was tongue in cheek
Sure, if you say so, but I didn’t see the emoji. So while that was evident to you, it wasn’t to others. Seems more like it gets under your skin to say Edman is the asset he has become because you have projected differently for him for a long time. What is clear is you and a couple others like to yank one guy’s chain over Edman. It’s okay if somebody is a huge Edman fan, he’s one of ours. Why is that an issue? And the fact this has gone on for a couple years, Edman’s continued success at everything the Cards have asked him to do makes it a challenge I’m sure.
he’s pretty much tailor made for the utility award.
See my comments on the criteria for the utility gold glove. I’d really like to see them. If you know, please point me to them. I don’t think they’re on the Rawlings site.
Edit to add: I posted this before I saw your last response addressing the subject.
Sure, that has some relevance. Is Law more or less accurate than other prospect services?
Comparing Law to any other service is also irrelevant to say that because “this guy” said it, I must have a better opinion than yours. It’s funny how people like to play that game. They all miss way more than they get right. How many 5th round draftees make it? 2nd round? 1st round?
So the pro tip is to take the George Constanza route — do the opposite. Always bet against what they say if it’s even money, and you’re sure to come out ahead.
So again, who are the three you have ahead of Edman? Or did that just seem right to say at the time?
Edman isn’t going to be top 3 in the Gold Glove shortstop order this year…
Please name the three you have ahead of him — it is an interesting topic to me. It is a stretch for me to come up with two, let alone three. But it depends on how voters view Edman since his time was spread almost evenly between two positions. From what I understand, each team’s 7 voters receive a list of players eligible for each position with their SDI ratings, which is weight 25% of the award. Some say this has influenced voters to go along with those ratings, which if so, in reality gives the SDI rating a much higher weight than 25%. I don’t think Edman is going to be outside the top 3 for that, or top 2 for that matter. I guess he will be #1 or #2.
What makes this interesting is the criteria for the utility gold glove haven’t been published. At least not that I have seen and I looked a week or so ago. The question I have is could someone now theoretically win two gold gloves in the same year, say 2B and Utility. Prior to this year, you could only win at the position for which you played the most innings. That would be shortstop for Edman. However, if he “qualifies” for the utility gold glove based on whatever criteria, then would that make him not eligible for gold glove at SS? If not, then it would be possible for a guy to win two gold gloves.
The possibility that Edman might win a gold glove at SS or the Cards might keep him at SS and Winn emerges at another position should not offend reasonable observers.
Whether he made great picks for this MLB season is irrelevant to this particular discussion.
Okay, do you care for me to list all the numerous prospects he’s whiffed on over the years? It’s numerous. Is that relevant? What’s irrelevant is he’s brought into the discussion to begin as if that validates someone’s view over another’s
BW, I guess I’m one of the “folks.” What does Keith Law have to do with this discussion? You brought him into it as someone’s opinion that should be listened to. I showed maybe he shouldn’t be. As for as prospects, I wish I had a dollar for everyone he has whiffed on one. For that matter, most do whiff. It’s a hard game to get right. Also, you were very critical of Pecota’s projections on the Cards 2022 season, yet they were much closer than Law. Why try to make apologies for Law now? That said, I hope he’s right about Winn.
Also, I didn’t see any attacking that I did. Just stating facts. Although this:
(even certain posters’ favorites)
is an obvious and unnecessary passive aggression to a certain poster for anyone who has read the board a few times.
In April, Keith Law predicted the Brewers and cubs would finish ahead of the Cards this year and the Cards would have a losing record.
This is exactly right willie. The Cardinals are a top down organization so having a manager who wants to do things his way is not what they are looking for.
gscott, we agree here for sure. Although I think I like the “puppet” metaphor a little better than willie’s figurehead description. It casts an image of the underlings doing next to nothing that is of their own accord on the broader strategic issues…or else.
If the pitcher was injured why was he on the roster in the first place? And who assigns the roster?
Is this your genuine take….that it was a roster issue? It was clearly reported on before and after the debacle. Helsley was injured October 4 and removed from the game. He was deemed healthy enough to be on the playoff roster. He felt fine when he came in to relieve October 7 in the 8th inning against the Phils. Soon thereafter, the injury reared its ugly head and he lost his feel of the ball, which led to something not normal going awry in the 9th. Surprised you didn’t know all that. Given those facts, the manager and pitching coach should be keenly aware they should be watching Helsley’s mechanics and command like a hawk.
This issue was not a roster decision. The issue was someone on the bench who could’ve mitigated an implosion occurring in real time needed to get his head out of his behind to make an obvious move sooner than he did.
Yankees extend their series with Cleveland to a 5th game.
Another interesting post-game panel discussion, this time by the TBS crew. Ernie Johnson asked a question about the rest for the top 2 seeds perhaps being a detriment since the Braves & Dodgers lost, the Yankees are extended in a big fight, and the Astros had their struggles at the plate. He wondered if the teams who get byes next year will maybe change their routines during their rest period.
Jimmy Rollins, Curtis Granderson and Pedro Martinez all weighed in. The two hitters said they want to play everyday. They needed that to stay sharp and have their swings geared to hit the top pitchers. You need to be seeing the live competition version of things such as different spins, different releases, all the variety, and those things can’t be effectively duplicated in batting practice. They felt pitching is different and rest can be a good thing.
I hope some of the Cards decision makers took some notes so next year if they are fortunate enough to clinch early, they don’t go all country club with the position players like the last couple seasons.
FIP actually focuses more on pitcher only performance in the context of what the pitcher can actually control himself, hence “Fielding Independent.” The inputs are HRs, Ks, and BBs (HBP too). It’s a three true outcome stat. Defense doesn’t come into play like it does with ERA+. FIP is more stable in that it doesn’t rely on defense or the luck of a hard hit ball becoming an out with no runs or a weak blooper driving in two runs. So FIP attempts to take out that “noise” to measure a pitcher’s performance. That’s why it is more stable over the course of a season or several seasons and why it’s a better predictor of what a pitcher will do next month or next season. ERA+ on the other hand, while it is a pitcher stat, is really a team defensive stat.
I guess a way to summarize it is a pitcher pitching one season for a good defensive team like the Cardinals and then the next season for a bad defensive team like the Nationals would be expected to have a similar FIP with both teams, but his ERA+ would likely be better with the Cardinals.
Pads slay the Dodgers to advance to the LCS against the Phillies. Right after the game, one of A-Rod’s first comments was interesting considering the Cardinals 1st wildcard game. He said you see it every year in the playoffs, teams pull a starter too early who is cruising, and it needs to stop. LA pulled Anderson after 5 shutout innings and the Pads broke through against the pen.
J-Rod with an outstanding catch to save Seattle, for the moment.
Cardinals were 2 full games better for the 102 games they played than anyone in the NL East in 1981.
A case of consistency being penalized
Reds were in a different division
I was clarifying for gscott the Reds had the best record in the NL.
Reds had the best record, but Cards had better than LAD.
Nah, it still wouldn’t count. Full seasons only, baby. Come to think of it, 1981 doesn’t count either, so that’s two reasons LAD should return that trophy, lol.
Is this homerism or arrogance
Sounds like a great idea to me. But to be consistent, LAD will need to return every World Series trophy they ever won to another team who won more games than they did during the season — well, except for 2020, which doesn’t really count anyway.
Duh, I made my post above after reading Brian’s reply #204546. After that post I began to read more posts above. Lol, disregard my post now, I thought I was on to something!
fans are very familiar with that team’s injuries, but pay less attention to other teams. We are all guilty of it.
You see this a lot. Even more in football I think.
Just a thought, but a “games missed” type stat could be even more telling. It could be a stat weighted by player value (expected WAR or something similar?) to truly show how damaging the missed games were, e.g., say next year luck runs very low and Goldy, Arenado and DeLuzio all miss 50 games. Which one of these things is not like the others?
Gorman’s 2022 trial at 2B looked pretty bad to me. Stats don’t look too good either. DRS was -6 in 548 innings, which projects to about -16 over a full season of innings. He played 2B like a DH, and if 2B is his most valuable position, he either must improve a lot soon or he’ll be a DH. If 2B doesn’t work out, I’d like to see him try the OF. How do we know 2B is “his” most valuable position? We don’t. Next year will reveal a lot.
1td, that can’t be. I was ready to put some money on Bader being the Postseason MVP. I didn’t know of anything about the playoffs today until the last 30 minutes. Just tuned in to the Braves-Phils then. I had forgotten the Yankees were playing until I read your post. I’m sure I’ll see a replay.
Brickhands Hoskins gives a run back. He’s gotta be glad that didn’t turn into more. He’s having a rough go with a couple key defensive miscues this series.
-
AuthorPosts
