Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Good addition, Mud. It’s a working list. 😉
Some of the very good players probably deserve some built-in equity, but performance needs to re-enter the equation fairly quickly. It’s hard to tell if the established players and union care more or less about the prospects than the owners do.
Perhaps the success of Edman and DeJong (both very good students seemingly of good character) is leading to Cardinals to place a premium on the whole person concept as to who they want to develop for the future.
This is a great time to stand up the MLBFA (F = Fans). Put owners and players on notice that fan attendance will not resume until the following conditions are met.
– Reduction in in ticket prices
– Reduction in parking prices
– Reduction in concession prices
– Reduction in merchandise prices
– Reduction in MLB.tv and other advanced media prices
– Reduction in cable TV / extra innings prices
– Elimination of TV blackout rules
– Etc.Fans see the world doesn’t end when pro sports go away. There are options — and this time more people will be forced to make some choices. Tolerance is pretty low for taking another shafting from the owners/players/agents and bailing out their greedy derrieres. That’s the current mood for many, but how durable will this attitude be?
June 6, 2020 at 8:52 pm in reply to: Resumption of spring training/regular season/playoff format #129828Hopefully, there is hope!
I fail to feel any of Heyman’s hope that Halem’s letter provides any hope.
June 6, 2020 at 6:22 pm in reply to: Resumption of spring training/regular season/playoff format #129818The late-March agreement essentially gave both sides veto power to starting the season due to qualifiers (health risks and limits on fan attendance). That gives the owners the leverage now since they are the side that wants the shorter season. The players seem to have little to no leverage since they don’t want to budge on pay per game.
I’d add this to any agreement to begin the season if I were representing the MLBPA. Since the extremely shortened season is based on empty stadiums, I would request an “attendance dividend” if fans are subsequently allowed to attend. Notice I didn’t say revenue sharing. 😉 Clearly the owners have made statements where you can now make a good estimate how much revenue is generated per attendance size. So the players should request a dividend based on how many fans end up attending games, to include playoff attendance. Maybe this line of thinking might also be used to encourage the owners to go for a bit longer regular season.
Unemployment data for May released this morning wasn’t nearly as bad as the forecast. Now that PPP loan forgiveness timelines are being met, we might see more layoffs in the next month. Not sure if this is applicable with The Athletic (46 is 8% of 575, so perhaps not).
June 4, 2020 at 2:48 pm in reply to: Resumption of spring training/regular season/playoff format #129738New odds courtesy of BetOnline (www.BetOnline.ag, Twitter: @betonline_ag).
Will there be an MLB regular season?
Yes -500 (1/5)
No +300 (3/1)Here’s an update:
Will there be an MLB regular season?
Yes -300 (1/3)
No +200 (2/1)June 3, 2020 at 5:51 pm in reply to: Resumption of spring training/regular season/playoff format #129710Are the players contractually bound to play under this arrangement (e.g. no further bargaining allowed)?
I don’t think the players are bound. The late March agreement was reported by Passan. I’m not sure if the actual agreement was ever made public, so I’m going with what Passan reported. He reported the agreement on prorated pay, but said there were qualifiers to beginning the season. One qualifier was there would be no bans on mass gatherings limiting play in front of fans, otherwise they would have to come up with solutions that were agreeable to BOTH sides. One of the other qualifiers was that “medical experts determine games will not pose a risk to health of teams and fans.” That qualifier, taken literally, means they would never start the season. At a minimum, I would take it as an easy out for either side in these negotiations.
All of the protests and riots could lead to a significant uptick in COVID-19 cases in a couple weeks, which might derail things. On the other hand, if cases remain stable or go down, that might indicate the virus is really losing steam and give more confidence to move ahead.
This could work out. MLB giving on pro-rata salary is big. 50-60 game regular season schedule perhaps.
I started to post this earlier in response to bikemike’s suggestion that maybe there’ll be a 60-game schedule. It’s the middle ground that meets the owner’s numbers (if you’re willing to believe those).
So do the math. The Spotrac tweet above says the 82-game prorated player salary cost would be $1.9B. The owner’s scaled offer was $933M for 82 games, which is about half. That means the number of prorated games needs to be halved down to about 40 to meet the owner’s willingness to pay $933M in salary. However, they can probably go more than 40 games since they won’t be losing as much overall by playing fewer than the original 82 games that they proposed (remember they say they will lose more money for each game played). So maybe 60 games is about the sweet spot.
Both sides are negotiating like they’re not hurting for money enough to get a quick resolution. Problem is much more of the fan base that ultimately pays them both is hurting for money and might not care so much if they figure it out this year. These economic impacts will stick around a while. More critical consumer choices will be made due to lower discretionary spending, at least temporarily. Sometimes people’s temporary decisions turn into permanent ones.
If there is an agreement it will occur in the 11th hour.
Most likely. Last is first.
. . . . it was kind of a downer. Yeah, we got Yadi in the fourth round in 2000, but there wasn’t another player who turned out to be a real game changer in any draft after that.
You know this biz is hit and miss, but this thread lets you know how tough it really is. Too bad a guy named Swackhamer didn’t make it. There was some marketing pop there.
The late March agreement for prorated pay had qualifiers on when the season would begin. As reported by Passan at that time, one of those conditions was there would not be bans on mass gatherings limiting fan attendance. That condition had a caveat which said if no fans are allowed, then the two sides would consider the feasibility of playing in empty stadiums to see if that approach works for both sides.
So, for those like Eugene Freeman who are saying to not pay full prorated salaries is counter to the March agreement, the empty stadium scenario is precisely the situation in which the March agreement calls for a joint reconsideration.
All the above assumes Passan was accurate in his reporting on the agreement. It was widely reported by various media outlets and he was often quoted by those outlets. I haven’t seen any specific report to invalidate that. Also, I have not been able to find the documented agreement itself.
The Major League Baseball Players Association plans to send a proposal with economic terms to MLB by the end of the week, sources familiar with the discussion told ESPN. As @Max_Scherzer tweeted, the players do not plan to make any salary concessions.
— Jeff Passan (@JeffPassan) May 28, 2020
My post was similar to what bccran just posted. It’s not my opinion directly of the Hernandez situation. It’s my opinion (or explanation is a better word) of why I think many fans think the way they do about him. Since comparing McGwire and Hernandez was brought up, one’s sin is clearly viewed more harshly. McGwire, like many others, cheated for performance reasons. Hernandez’ sin is viewed as worse I believe because it was an assault against the birds on bat, viewed as almost treasonous. Traitors aren’t often forgiven.
Again, that’s just my explanation, not my view. I liked Hernandez a lot during his Cardinal years. As for the Mets, I couldn’t muster enough disdain to worry about Hernandez. After Carter, Dykstra, Knight, and Strawberry, there was none left for Hernandez. He was too low on the list.
It would be interesting if all players give up money now to protect the relatively fewer free agents and arbitration eligible players this winter.
Brain, did you mean to say this?
It would be interesting if all players give up money now to protect the agents this winter.
Seriously, I wonder if the agents would benefit the most.
Yogi had the funeral thing figured out when he said you better go to their funerals, or they won’t come to yours.
Koch’s lamenting of Moreno’s net worth is probably his way of expressing the core values he lives daily. I bet he doesn’t give the babysitter just $15 an hour. He probably gives $50 or more an hour if he thinks his net worth is more than the sitter’s. Does he tip the waiter $20 on a $100 meal? Nah, it’s probably more like $75 if he thinks he’s worth more than the waiter.
Brian, bccran:
I think there’s a third reason. Though intertwined, it’s not fully captured with those two choices. It was Hernandez being labeled a “cancer” on the field and in the clubhouse by Whitey. I haven’t carried strong opinions forward on this, but some have.
Americans are usually great about forgiving (and even praising) their heroes for overcoming personal problems like drug abuse. Fans also are generally understanding when players leave for another team, especially if due to a fair trade (see Simmons). However, some saw Hernandez as responsible for forcing Whitey to a bad deal because he was not committed to the birds on bat. They saw him as just the opposite–not hustling or putting in the time while leading other Cardinal players down the white powder lane.
That is what some can’t forget, regardless of any reconciliation the principal parties have since made. That Hernandez did well with the Mets was just salt in a wound that already existed.
Right. Working the deal out themselves might be more likely than coming to agreement on an arbitration process and selection of arbitrators.
Nightengale is pleading that the sport will be “destroyed” if they don’t come to terms. Pretty clear which side he is on.
Brian, I think the article did at least touch on the concerns of both sides. Regardless, as time goes on, what I’m reading and hearing is there aren’t nearly as many people who will be devastated with a lost season as the owners and players would like to believe. Fans always seem to come back eventually, but this is a storm of a different pedigree.
If the delay carries on too long, maybe they could shift to a World Baseball Classic type of event or an NCAA tournament type event with pool play/short series, maybe leading to a final four (LCS and World Series). You definitely would not need as much calendar time. You could start “spring” training as late as August and run the event though early November. Each game would be a high-leverage event that would make for premium TV. Seems like there would be good bang for the buck for the millionaires and billionaires.
Actually no too bad for 748 tests. About .008 positives . . . . . stay away from older people or people with autoimmune problems. Needs to be a way to identify those folks.
This quote, plus the mental health issues stated above, are why we need to be looking at every opportunity for more targeted protections. The mass approach is causing huge other problems. It’s not pleasant for most retired and currently working people, but I imagine their stress doesn’t even register compared to families who need the next paycheck to pay for food and rent.
And why the “my one-year old just died” comment in that tweet and article? Way to misrepresent the crux of this issue. A one-year old probably has a better chance of dying countless other ways. They have a great issue to report, but that kind of hyperbolic headlining turns off so many. I guess it also sucks in a lot of others.
May 17, 2020 at 8:33 pm in reply to: Former Cardinals in the News – 2017 to Aug. 2024 (closed) #128905Yep, Howe’s age gave serious cause for concern. Glad it didn’t progress to the point of intubation.
gscott, you know a lot then. I’ve just read about the “certify in good faith” requirement (see my post above), but what does that really mean in numbers? It would seem to me for a company to be on sound footing in an audit, they would have to base the certification on real numbers from things like income statements, cash flow statements, balance sheets, equity statements, etc. Is it more specific than that?
-
AuthorPosts
