Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
The Just Baseball podcasters propose a trade of Brendan Donovan and Pedro Pages to Seattle for Jurrangelo Cijntje, catching prospect Luke Stevenson and infield prospect Nick Becker.
I don’t see any catchers involved in the trade.
Seattle just signed Knizner to be backup, and the Cardinals system is loaded in catchers. Cardinals need OF, 3B and pitching prospects.
If Boston misses out on Bregman then Donnie might very well be their plan B.
I think Paredes is the backup plan for Bregman. Donovan could be a complement to both.
December 31, 2025 at 8:42 am in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2024-2026 #298488Yeah, if Giolito is still out there a week or two before spring training, his price might fall to the Cardinals range…It sounds like he has had zero discussions with anybody so far.
As for Sheehan, I don’t see the Dodgers trading pitchers from their major league roster. If the Cardinals are punting on 2026, which it appears they are, then I prefer prospects anyway.
I was thinking that Seattle would only have $9.5M left which would effectively stop the Cardinals from putting together a bigger package. I don’t think Donovan alone is enough to bring back one of Seattle’s top pitching prospects. Adding Romero might be enough.
I am seeing this a lot, in the proposals. Everyone realizes major league players are more valuable that prospects, right? There’s a reason most trades involve multiple prospects for one major leaguer. We are just too accustomed to Mozeliak’s strategy which prioritized not trading away prospects at all.
And this report on MLBTR indicates the Mariners are willing to include at least one top pitching prospect.
My guess is, the Cardinals are holding out to see if another club misses out on their top choices and is willing to offer a bigger package.
Also, the Mariners front office has indicated they will have the potential for a trade deadline budget increase, just like they did this year.
There are still pundits that say Seattle makes the most sense for Donovan to be traded. But that just doesn’t add up financially. The Mariners only have $15.5M to work with and an acquisition of Donovan would take up $5.5M of that.
How does this not add up financially?
Seattle has $15.5 million of room, and Donovan is only projected to cost $5.5 million…
Looking at the Red Sox fan sites, people over there are convinced the Red Sox are okay exceeding the first luxury tax tier, but are trying to stay under the second tier.
The Cardinals could take back Patrick Sandoval (Bloom loves injured starting pitchers). in a Donovan trade to increase the prospect return for Donovan.
I do see the Rangers as a possible landing spot for Donovan.
The trade of Semien for Nimmo opens up 2B. Nimmo + Donovan is cheaper than Semien and will produce more WAR, so they improve the team, plus lower payroll. And they have a bunch of pitchers in their Top 10, though none of them are Top 100 prospects.
Brendan Donovan for Brayan Bello. Who says no?
Boston.
I think Bello is a part of their rotation in 2026, and if you take him out, you have to replace him.
It looks like Bregman is their #1 choice, followed by Ketel Marte. They still need right-handed hitters in their lineup.
As CIFCT said, the Cardinals would also be wasting two years of Bello.
I just don’t see this as a deal that would even merit beyond a cursory discussion.
December 25, 2025 at 11:22 am in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2024-2026 #298231Also, Curtis Taylor is still a free agent.
The Cardinals might bring him in as their “veteran innings eater”!!!!
I don’t relish the thought of the team becoming the dregs of MLB. Is that a concern to others?
Yes
The main question here is how many years, if any, do you plan on giving the team a pass on performance/lack of, in order to become at least a division winner?
I can’t support a billionaire chasing welfare dollars instead of trying to win a championship.
Has there been any indication that anybody out there would actually want Gorman in a trade, even at black Friday prices?
Yes, the Pirates inquired about Gorman, which is probably one more team than has inquired about Arenado.
You may be disappointed. There’s been multiple quotes by Bloom saying that he believes Walker will have success at the major league level and that going to aaa doesn’t help that happen.
Which is the same lunacy Mozeliak offered up.
At some point, somebody in the Cardinals organization is going to realize the bottom fell out of the organization when they decided they couldn’t spend $5-10 million on a right-fielder, and instead had to push Walker up from AA, despite knowing he couldn’t catch a ball.
The guy has cost the Cardinals tens of millions of dollars in lost revenue and millions in profits.
But keep repeating the same mistake over and over….
Then, the cycle is reversed. Play better, more fans come. More fans mean more revenue. More revenue means more expense. More expense means spending to get better players to add to the inexpensive ones.
I am not sure the Cardinals are ever going to go back to the model where they are spending 100% of their own money as opposed to collecting welfare from other MLB owners.
https://x.com/IanCundall/status/2002920990192656525
I can’t get the link to show in the post.
So, for those that don’t want to click:
Don’t think it’s a coincidence that the three pitchers the Red Sox dealt for Wilson Contreras all have fastballs that struggle to miss bats consistently. The highest whiff rate of the trio was 16%. MLB average was 21-22%.
Hunter Dobbins 11.9%
Yhoiker Fajardo 12.9%
Blake Aita 16%The Cardinals got less of a return than they got for Gray.
I guess this was the law of supply and demand, since it doesn’t seem like there were too many teams looking for a 1B.
But hey, DeWitt gets to save some more money!
The main thing this does is slots Contreras in as the 1B and hopefully he never touches the OF grass again as he is a defensive liability.
He’s played roughly 40 games in the outfield in his 10 year career, and none since joining the Cardinals. Not sure why this is your peeve.
Donovan’s versatility is nice, but should be used more in the case of injury because he is, by far, most valuable playing 2B regularly, in which case he is redundant due to Wetherholt’s timeline.
Bob posted this summer that Donovan actually grades out best at 3B.
Gorman has been mentioned in a few trade rumors, and we know they are trying to ship out Arenado. So, what if they trade Arenado & Gorman instead of Arenado & Donovan?
I don’t think they will actually keep Donovan, but it could happen.
Bling, I agree. If he has a solid April & May, flip him before the deadline. Don’t risk him breaking.
but then they spend twice as much on injury-riddled longshot Dustin May as they would have to pay Brendan Donovan in 2026. May is an overpaid, one-year, win-now acquisition.
I agree with the commentary, however, I don’t see May as a “win-now” move. He is a lottery ticket, where the Cardinals are hoping he will play well enough that he brings back a prospect haul at the deadline.
He somehow brought backs James Tibbs III and Zach Erhard at the deadline last year, who now rank as the Dodgers #8 & #27 prospects. Tibbs was drafted 13th overall in 2024, and Erhard was drafted in the 4th round.
If the Cardinals can con someone into giving up a similar prospect package at this year’s trade deadline, I am sure they will be ecstatic.
I think that Arenado’s defense alone could give the Mariners 2 or 3 more wins than anybody else they could put on 3B.
It’s funny that we need to trade him because he is bad and blocking younger players, but other teams need to trade for him to block younger players because he is good.
two more guys that will start 20+ games and throw 100+ innings is a necessity.
Which is exactly where they were before the May signing.
Dustin May is a $12.5 million lottery ticket.
You know that the Cardinals likely just threw $12.5 million away, but there is that miniscule hope he won’t break down and he’ll realize his potential and the Cardinals can cash in.
If they were only paying May $5-7 million, it would have been an okay signing.
Maybe the Cardinals have entered the territory where they have to overpay people to come here.
December 18, 2025 at 3:44 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2024-2026 #297823Does the FO think that this is the final answer to fix up the rotation???
Cardinals Still Looking for Rotation Help
According to MLBTR, the Cardinals are still looking for a starter
December 16, 2025 at 3:06 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2024-2026 #297700I also like Refsnyder. He mashes LH pitching.
The Cardinals would actually have a decent team if they acquired Refsnyder for LF, brought back Abreu as part of a Donovan + Contreras trade to Boston, and then signed a pitcher like Littell in free agency.
-
AuthorPosts
