Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
“Edman isn’t going to be top 3 in the Gold Glove shortstop order this year”.
“Edman’s value as a utility player will come in handy when Winn is ready, for sure. Winn has a great ceiling with the glove and I think we’ll see that quickly upon call-up”
Your opinion, not mine.
Winn’s ceiling is not greater than Eddie’s.
The only reason that Edman won’t win the GG at SS this year is that he played at 2B for the first half of the year. I think MLB created a GG for Utility players(multi-positional players) and Eddie should win it.It is not a different situation in any way. Walker and Gorman were moved because of Arenado. Winn should be moved because of Edman. Winn profiles as a CF’er IMO just like Gorman and Walker profile as corner outfielders IMO. The Cardinals are a better team with Tommy Edman at SS. Mine is not speculation but rather an observer and a lifelong baseball person as a player, coach and spectator of baseball. I am 73 years old.
bcc is correct IMO. No one is challenging Winn’s ability. Edman should be the Cardinal’s SS for many years to come and Winn should be groomed to be the CF’er. Gorman and Walker were moved…why not Winn? He definitely fits the profile of a CF’er…just like Walker and Gorman fit the profile of a corner OF’er. I don’t like Law because he doesn’t like college baseball and I do.
bcc…Gomez is an interesting player. Lots of power last year.
I cannot stand Keith Law and run from anything that creep has to say.
I do not think that and never have. He is fast and has a big arm=CF.
bcr…this is what I envision.
LF-Gorman
CF-Winn
RF-Walker
DH-Burleson/Yepez
2B-Donavan
SS Edman
3B-Arenado
1B-Goldschmidt
Need to sign a catcher to go with KniznerI don’t think we sign a free-agent outfielder…I think it is more likely we sign a utility infielder to take DeJong’s spot for a year.
“Edman ranked 3rd in defensive WAR in the major leagues this season. All positions included”
This…he certainly is a GG SS in 2022.Edman is a glove SS also…that is why his 2022 WAR is so high.
bcc…yes that would be potentially good backups.
O’Neill is the key to how the Cardinals adjust their outfield for next year. If they trade him then I would align the outfield to look like this:
Carlson
Nootbar
Burleson
Walker
Nolan GormanEventually, the starting outfield would be:
LF-Gorman
CF-Carlson
RF-Walker
Please don’t anyone say that Gorman can’t play LF because if he can adjust to 2B he can certainly LF. Walker is adjusting to the outfield and seems good at doing so.“Who cares about all those stupid analytical terms? As Herzog was quoted as saying a few years back, “Just give me batting average and then the eye test”. That’s all I need to know”….
The answer to that is every Front office in MLB.
Donavan and Eddie should always start over Gorman. Wait and see on Winn. Gorman is a hitter first and you find a place to play him…DH, LF or 1B.
Gorman should be a future 1B or in LF.
“No one speaks for Edman. His numbers do the talking”
This is correct.
Gorman needs to be moved to 1B/LF/DH.
Eddie did not digress this season. He got better…he finished 13th in WAR in all of MLB. The Cardinals should sign him to a long-term contract now. Eddie does not disappoint.
“– Could use an upgrade at Shortstop … Edmund will do, but it is time to move on from PDJ. I like Donovan as a super sub as he can handle numerous positions and it provides roster flexibility”.
First of all, at least spell Edman’s name right. Eddie is a gold glover so there are not many shortstops that are upgrades. Eddie at SS and Donavan at 2B is an outstanding middle infield and should be the number 1 & 2 hitters in the line-up.
Give Edman a long-term contract now.
October 7, 2022 at 7:36 pm in reply to: 2022 Wild Card Series Game 1 thread – Friday, October 7 vs. Phillies #2037551td…if Helsley couldn’t grip a baseball then that should have been determined before he went out there.
October 7, 2022 at 7:09 pm in reply to: 2022 Wild Card Series Game 1 thread – Friday, October 7 vs. Phillies #203745How is pitching not a strength? The Phillies scored zero thru 8 innings and a usually reliable Ryan Helsley was pitching the ninth.
October 7, 2022 at 1:06 pm in reply to: 2022 Wild Card Series Game 1 thread – Friday, October 7 vs. Phillies #203562667…Dickerson behind Yadi isn’t the same as Eddie. Eddie can fly.
October 7, 2022 at 12:23 pm in reply to: 2022 Wild Card Series Game 1 thread – Friday, October 7 vs. Phillies #2035561td…I hope with this current order that Yadi goes 4 for 4 with 2 HRs and 2 doubles.
October 7, 2022 at 11:50 am in reply to: 2022 Wild Card Series Game 1 thread – Friday, October 7 vs. Phillies #203549The line-up is obvious but the order is wrong. I would have gone:
1. Donavan
2. Edman
3. Goldschmidt
4. Arenado
5. Pujols
6. Nootbar
7. Carlson
8. Molina
9. Dickerson -
AuthorPosts
