Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Alcantra now on in relief. Preparing him for a bullpen role in STL?
I dont see Ravello as even staying in the org. Unless put on what is an already crowded 40 man roster he will be a minor league FA. With Voit and Carpenter ahead of him not sure why he would come back as a minor league FA.
Not trying to be contentious but a guy might be an everyday starter for 20 games and not cut it. Is he considered a starter? Is a guy that sees 10 games in the bigs as a bench player never to be heard from again considered to have made it as a bench player?
If it is up to me, I non tender him. If he wants to sign for 3/9 with incentives for games finished I’d talk.
Define “starter” and “bench”. How long does a player have to be in that situation to count?
I read the post above without noting who posted it. When I got to Voit as ” starter” I already knew. Lol
Scott Hurst is 11-12 starting with his last two AB’s on 8/18. That has raised his BA about 40 points in 4 days.
No 40 man spots but my guess is Rosenthal could go on the 60 day DL anytime they needed a spot.
2 comments.
1. If Oquendo is that sensative as to get upset over one disagreement in philosophy, maybe he is not the man some think he is.
2. I never thought Oquendo was a particularly good decision maker as a 3rd base coach.
Maybe because Josh Lucas isnt on the 40 man roster?
As crazy as it sounds, I hope they bring up Wick. Let him earn or lose is 40 man roster spot.
I have supported Helsley as much as anyone here. But to be fair, you cant ignore the ages of Fernandez and Hicks compared to Helsley.
That will free nearly $10 million in payroll but leave us without a closer. Also increases chance of Seigrest returning. Not sure that is a good thing.
Machado doesn’t have to be protected yet.
Mejia will not be a minor league FA this winter.
But agree with most of the rest. Don’t believe Sosa would make it through waivers though. If Gomber is unprotected I believe we lose him.
I dont think Hensley throws hard enough that he could have so much success if he didnt either change speeds or have movement. Even pinpoint control wouldn’t get you that good of results.
Is that accurate on Grichuk? I didnt realize he had been that good.
I’m not sold on Mercado as worth protecting. He has dropped off a lot and I think it is unlikely he would stick all year on a major league roster (not even the Padres). Add in the fact that he is probably about #11 on our OF depth chart, it would not be the end of the world if we lost him.
Mejia showing he wants another crack in September – batting .358 in July and August.
August 12, 2017 at 11:19 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #30511In 2 years Martinez replaces Carpenter at first! 🙂
This team cares about defense?
Valid arguments Jag. I think the Cards for go tbe third catcher this year. I think your fave Valera is more likely to go than Mejia but hard to say.
Wick is pitching better lately. Tough call to give up his potential for the seemingly greater certainty of Montgomery.
Ironic that Carpenter nearly screwed over Rosenthal after his earlier criticism of Rosenthal. Hopefully Rosenthal holds his tongue.
Would this season be different if Lyons had been healthy all season?
Jag, to make your additions you would need to remove 4 players from the 40 man roster. Who would you choose?
Basic rule for rule 5 eligibility – 4th rule 5 draft after signing if 19 y.o or above at time of signing. 5th rule 5 draft if 18 y.o. or less at time of signing.
An intersting case is Alcantra. He signed in 2013 but did not play. But that makes this his 5th rule 5 draft and thus eligible even though he has the same number of minor league seasons as Junior Fernandez who signed in 2014 and is not eligible.
I actually had hope that Helsley would pull a Rosenthal and go from low A one season to STL the next.
If it were all stats, Pearce would also be ranked higher.
August 12, 2017 at 4:52 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #30489Given we still have Carpenter I think we should be targetting J.D. Martinez instead of Hosmer (of course a lot of other teams will be doing so also).
-
AuthorPosts
