Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
I’m going with the pitcher here who I think gives the Cardinals the 2nd most long-term value. I have him a notch behind Mathews and just a smidgeon ahead of Doyle as all my 2-6 picks came in close together. There is something absolutely comforting watching the smooth delivery of Tanner Franklin. He repeats everything well. The velocity jumps out of his hand without him looking like he’s having to throw hard. And the results have been there since his day 1 debut. He’s the pitcher I’m the most excited to see debut one day in a Cardinals uniform.
5. Tanner Franklin
I completely echo Bling here. Baez has always been an outfielder. He should continue to get a little better. But with Walker, he had no experience ever playing outfield so his improvement level was always going to be a lot quickly, especially given his natural tools.
In Baez’s defense though. If I were guessing, he probably played LF the least of the 3 outfield positions. Maybe we will see solid improvement in his reads with reps. He has all the physical tools where he should be able to get to better than average, but he’s clearly well behind that now.
1TD – He’s so far off to a far better start to his career than Winfield! His first season is better than any of Winfield’s first 3 for certain, and maybe any of his first 6 if you’re looking at overall value. He was better than Trout’s first season too, but Trout’s 2nd season may be tough to catch!
October 9, 2026 at 5:47 pm in reply to: The Cardinal Nation’s Team Recaps and Top Players of 2026 #320819Ahh yes – I do remember Pachecho now. He was kind of a lower rung prospect. Glad to know it’s not a totally hopeless title, but it’s close to it since even he never made the Show. I generally figure that if they are already a reliever in the DSL, that’s not good for them long-term. Plus, because there is such an advantage to being 19 over 16 or 17 in physical stature, generally the players of the year will be older in the DSL and older is usually also not a good sign. Mr. Irrelevant indeed.
4. Bernal (my 3, but I’m perfectly ok with the #4 selection here – hopefully).
I agree with much of what “25” said above except that I think it’s a good possibility he makes a couple All-Star teams in his peak years. I think he’s going to generally be a 2.0-3.5 WAR player which is a very solid player to have with maybe a couple peak years north of 4. He is still pretty young though so he could still find another gear.
For the Cardinals, he is hopefully the answer at Catcher for some time to come (unless Raniel stays there). He’s been good at managing pitchers, rates well at blocking and framing, and has a good arm. Not that it matters here, but he complements better with Herrera or Pages as the other Catcher due to Bernal being overall better from the left side of the plate. This puts Crooks in a bit of limbo.
October 9, 2026 at 12:04 pm in reply to: The Cardinal Nation’s Team Recaps and Top Players of 2026 #320793Always the most irrelevant of these selections, the DSL Reliever of the Year now adds the fact that you had to choose the best of 2 mediocre guys since everyone else was terrible.
I’m curious if any DSL Reliever of the Year has ever made the Majors? I’m pretty certain it’s a no. I’m not even sure one has ever made it to AAA.
The small market guys are doing ok.
Or the small markets are doing horrendously bad over the past 25 years but this year may be an outlier. We shall see. If it ends up Dodgers/White Sox, then smaller markets will have lost yet again.
Couple of interesting facts:
8 of the top 10 spenders made the playoffs this year. That made up 2/3 of the playoff teams. This also included 7 of the top 10 teams in revenue. No surprise there as that’s about how many make it every season.
Only the Dodgers are left from that group. That could be in part because these teams beat up each other. The Brewers did beat the Padres though. And the Rays beat the Yankees.
So it was very difficult for the little guys to get in, but they’ve had good success after arriving.
I’m really curious to see how the Rays finish as they are one of the “have-nots” that seem to never win it all as a bottom 10 revenue team. The Brewers, while no longer a bottom 10 revenue team due to some recent successful seasons, used to be bottom 10 and haven’t been to the World Series since 1982.
Correction – Peete actually stole 3 bases as opposed to the 1 listed here.
I did mean any of our top 50 prospects. That isn’t a real restriction on the actual team, but right now they seem to be in the hoard prospects mode. I didn’t want someone proposing to trade 8 prospects to get to the value of one certain MLB player, which the Cardinals would never do right now. But could they trade Colton Ledbetter or Brayden Davis? Sure. But I’m not sure how valuable that is.
Just for comparison, here’s how Milwaukee finished by FWAR for each position:
4th best at C (compared to 14th for Cardinals)
2nd best at 1B (compared to 13th)
Best at 2B (compared to 5th)
18th best at 3B (compared to 30th)
8th best at SS (compared to 21st)
3rd best at LF (compared to 22nd)
27th best at RF (compared to 13th – We win one!)
18th best at CF (compared to 29th)
18th best at DH (compared to 20th)
4th best at Starting Pitchers (compared to 12th)
4th best at Relief Pitchers (compared to 25th)Milwaukee did have 4 under-performing positions with RF being especially bad. However, they were top 5 with six of their positions including both sets of pitchers. I guess if you’re top 5 in basically half of everything, you’re going to be really good as long as you don’t stink everywhere else. The Cardinals had one top five finish (2B) and were only better than Milwaukee in one area (RF).
-
This reply was modified 1 month, 1 week ago by
Jnevel.
This round could be ultra close again. We have 4 more (maybe 5) potential star prospects that each has a unique reason why someone might decide they are the best fit at 3.
Leo Bernal has exceptional defense (at least in the Minors), could have good or better than good offense, and has a good reputation for handling pitchers. He’s a switch hitter who is generally better from the left side, which all bodes extremely well. I am a bit cautious because the small sample size we saw at the Majors for his offense was probably inflated. He sure looks like the full-time catcher of the future who we have been waiting for though. It’s a bonus that he can also play first base. I’m going with him as I think he provides the next most long-term value to the Cardinals organization behind Rodriguez and Mathews. Although I’m secretly hoping each or any of the next 3 on my list pass him because they all have more upside if they can achieve it.
3. Leonardo Bernal
People can change their minds based on information provided. I know I sometimes rethink a prospect based on points one of our posters might add. Heck, the back half of my list is still very fluid right now and could easily shift based on other’s thoughts & opinions.
This is an especially tough year because there are so many prospects to keep track of. My list of guys I’m trying to keep up with is 94 names long. It’s typically closer to 65.
I agree we don’t want to see someone swap out picks every round just to try to be in the majority though. But I haven’t really seen that (or at least haven’t noticed it).
Nyquis – I voted for Mathews early on.
I would rather it had stayed Cardinals, but the city owns the team so it’s theirs to do as they will. I wish they had picked a more clever, fun name if they were going to change it. It seems like they settled on a middle option where it’s sort of creative, but not too over the top. Over the top names seem to sell jerseys. This one is unremarkable.
Players the Dodgers didn’t buy as a free agent or trade for on their postseason roster:
Will Smith – drafted 1st round 2016
Andy Pages – signed out of Dominica in 2018
Josue de Paula – signed out of Dominica in 2022
Edguardo Henriquez – Signed out of Venezuela 2018I guess you can sort of count Roki Sasaki, but he was a professional and chose them.
I have Doyle at 5. He’s super close with everyone in the 2-6 range. When I run through probabilities, the highest probability for Doyle is he ends up as a reliever – likely because injury forces him there because of the high stress of his delivery or control forces him there. I love his current results. I love everything the development staff is doing with him. Because of it, he has the highest probability to become an “ace” of all the pitchers in our system. But if I were gambling and betting on the odds, I’d bet he spends most of his career as a reliever. Mathews on the other hand has very little reliever risk. He’s most likely a number 3 starter for years to come. He could become a 2 or a 4 depending on refinement or lack thereof but he’s probably a 3. That’s where my head is at on this one.
I do think we will learn a lot more about Doyle next season when we see him handle more advanced hitters and see the results with a major league ball.
I am also going with Quinn Mathews at #2. There a group of about 5 guys that are all quite close for numbers 2-6 for me. Quinn is the most proven of that group. Aside from one outing that went really poorly maybe in spite of solid pitching from him, his rookie performance at the MLB level was extremely good. He also was better at AA than our other pitchers I am considering here for spots 2-6.
2. Quinn Mathews
Right you are 27. I expect to see 4 or maybe even 5 different names put out there for the organization’s #2 prospect in our next round of voting.
This year is tough! I am trying to fit 75 worthy names into 60 slots. It feels criminal to leave any of them out. And in addition to those 75, there are still additional guys like Miura or Honeyman or Kross who would have easily made it onto a past prospect list – albeit in the 40’s. Those guys now would be in the 80’s on my list if I went that far.
Relief pitchers are far more likely to hit up against the service time eligibility rule first before they get to the innings threshold. I think we have removed guys in the past who got there so I think we should stay consistent and remove Gastelum, Prieto, and Winquest. I had no idea Winquest was there! I guess the Yankees helped that along even though he never got in a game!
I’m not sure why we would cut ties with Pages. He’s well worth that salary – even if he’s sitting at AAA as a contingency plan. He’s a perfect backup catcher complement who is already very familiar with the staff and plays excellent defense. Plus he’s a good “team” guy. Gorman on the other hand is a very likely non tender.
October 3, 2026 at 6:49 pm in reply to: Which Cardinal minor league pitcher has the best chance to be a positive #320249Bling – I’m with you on those you commented on. Clarke at #9 is absolute insanity – especially with Mathews at 8. Mathews has shown he can be an effective rotation piece at the MLB level with at least #4 as a floor. Clarke has shown he can pitch about 15 innings between each time he is injured. I don’t know how they can be equals.
I also agree with you on Frias. Not sure how he’s #5. He needs to do a lot more proving to be that high against our group of other great prospects.
Good call on Gastellum Gagliano. He shouldn’t be on our list as he is no longer rookie eligible. He came us July 8 and never went back down. He’s far past the 45 day eligibility mark.
October 3, 2026 at 2:11 pm in reply to: Which Cardinal minor league pitcher has the best chance to be a positive #320216Bling – You are right. That’s the real point here. It no longer matters if 2 key guys both fail because what used to be 2 key guys is now 15. Lots more depth is more likely to create success.
I was thinking about this with our prospect list. It’s not like numbers 1-8 are necessarily much better than they have been in recent years. But what used to be 8 real strong prospects is now 30. The number 29 guy on my list could have been number 8 four years ago.
-
This reply was modified 1 month, 2 weeks ago by
Jnevel.
-
This reply was modified 1 month, 1 week ago by
-
AuthorPosts
