Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Jnevel, re: your comments on keeping a spot open for Rule 5 draft. Is that just a general thought or are you thinking about specific players who might be left vulnerable and would be a good fit?
EuroDandy – Now I’m really confused.
Sorry about that. The process is confusing even after reading several articles on it. Regardless, MLB will announce December 1, 2023 which teams are awarded Competitive Balance picks in the 2024 Rule 4 draft.
I bet Mr Ballgame might be a little low on muscle mass now that he’s in his 50s. If you go see the Orioles play you might see Boog Powell at his barbecue stand talking to customers. A few years ago we did and he was not nearly as tall as I remembered him to be when I was a kid. I think the years humped him over a bit, LOL, as it does most of us.
DBacks add on. Going to the bottom of the 9th, now 9-1.
What do you guys think about Smoltz as an analyst?
1td, I think I heard Rosie was attractive in high school, even a homecoming queen. Who could’ve predicted then what she looks like now? 😉 I think she cleared waivers years ago.
Ha! I don’t grade anyone’s grammar or wording on a message board, especially my own.
Euro sounds like you are the one lecturing, but I regress.
Yes, I was lecturing you on not lecturing. 😉
But we are just going to have to disagree about this hindsight business.
Correct KCB, disagreements should happen sometimes and be okay . . . . . and sometimes productive.
O’Neill was a star. But just for 1 season. His 2021 was worth more than Garcia’s 2023 in FWAR. Yes. That is a fact. Injuries keep tanking him. He’s hardly a whiff.
Perennial = more than one year. I said he was a whiff because he was assessed to be a “perennial” star. Mo’s job is to get and keep prospects who will perform highly over multiple years, not find one-hit wonders. Star to you, whiff to me.
I don’t recall anyone saying we should have kept Garcia until after the fact.
So because you don’t recall, it didn’t happen? And that makes you feel like lecturing/telling others that they need to get in line and adopt your view, as you did in the following?
Who thought Lane Thomas could be an everyday outfielder? That’s what I thought……. So, congratulations to Garcia on his success and to Texas on their good fortune. But quit acting like anyone should have been able to predict it.
There were quite a few fans critical of the move at the time. I guess you weren’t reading twitter then. Even a few respected posters on this very sight said they didn’t like the move and talked about other moves Mo could’ve made.
Hindsight is perfect, yet some are defending it.
This is the weakest of all arguments to support a guys whose very job is to develop rosters of prospects and established players who will deliver future MLB performance. FORESIGHT is critical in Mo’s job and he needs to be evaluated on exactly that. It’s not easy, but he’s well compensated. I don’t think too many people judge him harshly based on one move. It’s the accumulation that is wearing on many fans. As for Garcia specifically, it is certainly a valid critique to say that you shouldn’t “give” away your most athletic prospect, which he was, because they usually have higher ceilings.
Which leads to another thing the Cards stubbornly adhere to at their detriment — the sunk cost fallacy. As an example, some fans thought Cecil should’ve been canned much earlier. Some people like to say you’ve got nothing to lose by hanging onto Cecil because you’ll still have to pay him, i.e., nobody would claim him if you waived him. That’s really a load of economic ignorance. Evaluate the players and get rid of the liabilities who have next to no chance of rebounding. You’re not getting the money back. You’re just compounding the problem by wasting a roster spot. It can have consequences such as we are discussing now.
Over the last several years, we’ve seen a manger here and couple coaches there get canned. These moves have come across to me as not much more than Mo having to do something to show he’s identifying problems and making corrections. A couple of years ago, I seem to remember Mo making some comments about not being thrilled with some of the data analysis or something similar that fell under Girsch’s realm. I thought that might be a setup, but then nothing happened.
I agree with TexasCard though, that these and any future similar moves won’t move the needle. You can’t keep jettisoning your best coaches and prospects and they don’t know why it’s happening. I think Mo might be damaged goods now. Even if he saw the light and wanted to upgrade the quality of his manager and coaches, what guy like Bochy or Maddux would want to work with him after how we’ve seen how Mo has shaped those roles? Those kind of guys don’t respond well to “shut up and color and if we want your opinion, we’ll ask for it.”
Yep, for any meaningful change, BDW is going to have to be the enforcer. I just think it will be too hard for him to do what he needs to do with Mo still in the picture.
If you search ‘rank MLB teams by market size’, or something similar to that, you will find several websites that use differcriteria than the criteria you refer to for determining market size. Regardless of that, we are not getting a Competitive Balance pick.
The competitive balance picks for the next draft aren’t published yet. MLB releases that in December each year, so we’ll know soon.
None of those various market size stats are relevant here. What matters is what MLB and MLBPA use, which is attachment 26 in the Basic Agreement. It has the Cards ranked 26 in market score. So that means they have a chance if the other factors align.
Since they started competitive balance picks (in 2012 I believe), the Cards have not qualified in just 3 of those years. One year was 2016 I think, along with 2022 and 2023. Maybe with their losing record this year, the Cards will qualify again for the next draft.
But yet, quite a few did predict he should’ve been kept. Quit acting like they didn’t.
I really enjoyed Game 1.
It was a good one. Didn’t you say you’re going to be in Phoenix? Attending a game?
Wow again. Garcia just walks it off with a lead off HR in the 11th.
Wow, what a way to get this WS started. Seager just hit a 2-run HR in the bottom of the 9th to tie the game.
How’d you like the way 43 trusted Pudge with the low breaking stuff on the 1st pitch?
Rangers off to a quick start. Garcia has already tied Freese in his first AB by collecting his 21st post-season RBI. He hit it hard off Gallen.
I believe there is a voting awards bias in favor of players on good teams and against those on bad teams
I recall decades ago an ACC basketball coach justifying why a couple of his players got all-conference awards over some other players many fans thought were better. That team won the championship and the coach said “to the victor go the spoils.” It does make sense that the awards would be overweight to the better teams. Better players, better teams — that’s usually how it works.
However, in this case it’s kind of the opposite. If you take the team records of the 10 winners and combine them, you get a losing record of 800-820. Or looking at it another way, only 4 of the 10 winners were on teams that made the watered down playoffs.
We weren’t in a 40 man roster crunch.
They had just signed Kim and needed to make room for him. They didn’t waive Garcia because they didn’t think he’d clear, so they grabbed the bag of balls from Texas. This is back when they had assessed Carlson and O’Neill to be their next perennial stars in the OF. Whiff, whiff.
Stuff that hurt, lol. I wondered too, but the article said the Cardinals declined to give details on what Melcher said.
Sure there’s a chance. A good comp is Lance Lynn getting a base hit. His career batting average is .085. So the chance is not quite as good as Lance getting a hit, but pretty close, ha!
And what if the Yankees get it, imagine the talk on that. It really is a remote chance, though, maybe even as low as a Rangers-DBacks WS.
It is literally the job of our front office and development team to “see it coming”. That is their job!
You are spot on, gscott. The criticism that fans shouldn’t critique in hindsight is nonsense. It’s the only way to eval an employee’s performance. I like to say they don’t pay Mo for his hindsight, his job is to deliver foresight.
Another deflection is “we don’t have all the information and aren’t qualified to question xyz decision.” I might not be a structural design expert and don’t have a clue why they used a welded joint versus a bolted joint, but when the building comes crashing down, I know the guys in charge of design, development and/or maintenance screwed up. We’ve been watching the building known as the St Louis Cardinals wobble the last few years and it pretty much crashed down in 2023.
stlcard’s post is also a good take.
Teachers were smart enough back then to know that requiring a classroom full of kids to watch and pay close attention to any WS game was far and away a more valuable and educational life experience than any old textbook could provide.
Ha, I never had any of those teachers. I do remember racing off the school bus just in time to see Gibson strike out the side for his 17th K in Game 1 of the 68 WS.
Lol, you’re not the only guy tonight who thought about Howard’s injury. In the bottom of the 9th tonight, I thought about Carpenter and Halladay, thinking I wouldn’t mind a repeat of their bottom of the 9th, except for the blown Achilles.
Big media has to be cursing these playoffs. It’s Arlington and Phoenix. Two storied big league towns steeped in a tradition of baseball excellence and emblematic of our national pastime.
-
AuthorPosts
