Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
I really doubt Wisdom gets claimed in the rule 5 (though not totally improbable). The guy hasn’t hit over .243 for a season since 2012. With his age, there is little hidden potential to be tapped.
11. Perez
12. Hicks
13. Helsley
14. Garcia
15. KnizerI’d rather have Cisheck than Nascio.
Trades are fun to speculate about but that speculation usually has little to do with reality. More so in our case. Too many moving pieces. I dont doubt their will be a significant trade – but who goes and for what is anybody’s guess.
Bhc – why so high on Soza?
I forgot about Wick. I would place him in the Mayers/Lucas category.
Note that Nicasio is also a FA after the season.
FA’s
Oh
Duke
Lynn
NicasioThis happens 5 days after the World Series. With bringing back Rosenthal and Reyes, the roster will stand at 38.
They need to add any potential minor league FAs to the roster at this time also if the want to protect them. That would include Martini and Montgomery. I dobt see them doing that.
In preperation for the rule 5 draft they will certainly remove some players. My guess (in order of likelyhood)
Rosario
Rosenthal (I’m predicting he gets a minor league contract laden with incentives)
Mejia – I think he passes through waivers and remains under team controlThat brings the roster to 35.
For rule 5 protection they will add
Gomber
Mercado
O’Neill
SeferinaThat brings the roster back to 39.
If they need to sign more than 1 free agent and haven’t opened up any spots via trade, these are the players who I think are most likely to get removed (in order).
Valera – probably passes through waivers but then becomes a minor league FA.
Voit – 50/50 if he passes through waivers. Cards retain his rights if he does.
Mayers – was outstanding after being moved to the Memphis pen. I think he gets claimed if put on waivers.
Lucas – personally, I would keep Mayers over him but the Cards seem to see it differently.
Sosa – Definately gets claimed if exposed to waivers.
Why does this team ( with help from others) keep giving me hope? I know they will just disappoint me in the end.
September 20, 2017 at 5:39 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #33573I think Senzel is a much better prospect than Kelly if his defense is good enough for 3B. I think it would take much more than Kelly. There is a reason they gave him $6.2 million.
They could release Rosario. They have shown MM isnt going to use Kelly or Molina anywhere else.
They most likely will drop one middle infielder in the off season. My guess it will be Mejia. No reason to keep him an extra 10 days.
No point in bringing up.Montgomery to drop a guy just as good.
If they want to waive the white flag, no reason not to go ahead and drop Oh or Duke.
Good info Pads. Sounds like a platoon candidate (with Sierra?). The problem is despite all our depth, we have very few LH bats.
The worst thing will be having to listen to nathan all winter.
I am going to argue that people need to really question Mercado as a top prospect. Did he really make a turn around or did he just have a hot 3 months? His second half batting avg was .243 with a .660 Ops. His OPS vs lefthanders for the year was .626. So what happened? Did he get tired. Did the league adjust and he didnt? I think for a player with so little previous success, 3 months of sucess followed by 3 of returning to normal doesn’t seem to warrant an extremely high ranking. I also do believe he should not be Rule 5 protected. He is just too much of a question mark.
Stubby with the exceptionally quick hook of Hudson may have cost the game. They are starters for a reason.
I had a virtual tie between Galen and Hicks for my 10th spot. Went with Galen because he’s closer. But surprised Hicks hasn’t made anyone’s top 10.
Anyone besides me who would like to see Arozarena playing 2B next year. He has played it before. Certainly he would have a clearer path.
6. Hudson
7. Alcantra
8. Sierra
9. Perez
10. GallenMartinez’ babip was only .215 despite an above avg line drive rate. Walk rate remains decent. I think he’ll bounce back.
September 18, 2017 at 3:50 pm in reply to: Trade Ideas/Acquisition Ideas/Non-Cards Rumors – 2017-2018 #33374Is there any team that wouldn’t?
Pearce with his best game of the year! Never have been high on Pearce but who knows.
Looking at Derek Shore’s list made me wonder why Seattle gave up on O’Neill. (Not trying to influence votes as O’Neill has already been selected). Anybody else still wonder that?
#5 Bader
Brian, with the scout site scuttled, is there anywhere to access the prospect lists from the past?
Another reason for changing who you are voting for from one round to the next is not wanting to waste one’s vote if it is obvious there is not going to be a consensus for the player you have next on your list. I have done this from time to time but I usually have stated my reasoning for doing so at the time I do it.
Was Alcantra impressive in striking out the side?
This is not a voting for the best non-rookie. It is a prospect vote. What makes a player a prospect? There has not been sufficient oppertunity to evaluate how they will perform at the major league level. A guy that comes up for 4 months and sits on the bench for 4 months and never plays is still a prospect in my book. One could argue that 130 ab’s or 50 ip is not sufficient either but you have to cut off somewhere. We have never used service time as a limiter on the prospect list. This is because when we started doing this list there were very few others doing them. The main one was BA and they also did not use service time as a cut off. Most lists still do not. I hope that clarifies things a little.
-
AuthorPosts
