Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
#4 Bader
I’ll admit that him over O’Neill may well just be familiarity bias.
The ones who ultimately disrespected Kelly was the STL FO.
Just because you think Bader’s value is solely based on him playing center doesn’t make it so. And for a guy that is extremely blocked there as a Cardinal he sure is playing a lot there. Besides, with Kelly you are argueing his prospect status is independent of whether he is blocked or not. Why wouldn’t the same apply to Bader?
Nyquis, I understand what you are saying about the fans, the media, etc., but what was gained by doing this a year early? Nothing that I can see.
I also think if for some reason Molina had ended up walking, the fans would have accepted it. The FO gained a lot of credibility in situations like this for what appears to be an excellent decision regarding Pujols. Not sure why they didn’t cash that in.
Lankford did it 5 times in the 90’s. The last being 1998.
Herget with 15k’s. If he was consistent, he would be in the prospect discussion.
Gallen is pretty amazing. Extremely rare to find a 21 y.o. college pick pitching in AAA as a starter. Extremely rare!
Pads, it is Bader’s brief big league performance that has put him ahead of Kelly for me. It is not just his hitting but also his defense and just his overall presence that lead me to that conclusion. Kelly’s stock hasn’t gone down but Bader’s has gone up.
Wisdom will most likely be back in Memphis next year unless selected in the rule 5 draft. He is not a minor league FA until after 2018.
Bader #3
I couldn’t find BA’s criteria. At times it appeared they took the guy with the best stats but there were times that they clearly didn’t.
Several Cards prospects split time between leagues thus probably not qualifying for consideration in either league. (Helsley, Flaherty, and O’Reilly specifically come to mind).
Flaherty #2
But dont forget, Reyes has shown (when healthy) he can perform at the major league level. Kelly hasnt.
September 12, 2017 at 1:50 pm in reply to: The Cardinal Nation’s Team Recaps and Top Players of 2017 #32829What happened to Leandro Cedeno who started off hot in the GCL?
Hey, I’m CC!
Valera did not use an option by being called up for a few days. That option was already burnt when he was optioned to Memphis to open the season.
Voit could pass 130 ABs still but it seems unlikely. It would be a shame if he did. Then we wouldnt get to debate with bccran about him being underated.
Bader could pass 130 only if he started every game the rest of the year which also seems unlikely.
Reyes #1
I would not want them to sign him for 3 years unless they were going to trade Kelly.
It also comes down to the reality of $20 million spent on Molina is probably $20 million not spent elsewhere. Molina next 3 years or Kelly and Lance the next 3 years? I take Kelly and Lance. Does Molina keep you out of the Machado market after next year?
Even so, do you think the risk of Molina getting hurt or starting his decline in 2017 warranted an off season signing that almost surely could have happened for the same price this off season?
And a huge distraction would have meant what? We would have languished in 3rd place in the division most of the year?
These guys are pros. If that would have been a huge distraction, not a guy I want on my team.
He may have declined the mutual option but I dont think he is getting 3/60 anywhere else.
And Colorado air reduces strikeouts?
I hope something has clicked with O’Neil. Over his last 10 regular season games and the playoffs he has cut his k rate almost in half to abot 15%. He hasn’t sacrificed offense hitting well over .300 with an OPS over 1.100 during that time.
Another outfielder that has been overlooked is Adolis Garcia. Even though he spent significant time in AA, in his time in AAA he has shown he is major league ready.
I like that we control our own destiny.
39 runs in 3 games. The air must be super light this time of year in Colorado.
A lot of outstanding offense but the performance that stands out to me is Mayers. Almost every other pitcher stunk it up while he pitched several games of multiple innings without giving up a run.
No wait and see for me unless they trade Kelly. I’d be shocked if Molina earned that contract. His last 3 years wouldn’t make it worthwhile. I don’t see how 3 years of aging is going to help.that going forward. Add Kellu wasting away on the bench and the deficit gets worse.
My take: 1. You dont pay for past production. 2. Does anyone think he wouldn’t have signed for that amount at the end of the year? 3. I dont think any other team would pay him near that amount (making it the opposite of a home town discount)
Despite that, I dont have a big issue with it if it wasnt for the presence of Kelly. But you dont keep two starting level catchers just because one might get hurt.
The NYPL always plays until about this date.
-
AuthorPosts
