Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
August 19, 2022 at 7:37 pm in reply to: 2022 Cardinals MLB Game 118 thread – Friday, August 19 at Arizona #196348
Edman is not below average in any area of baseball.
August 17, 2022 at 3:21 pm in reply to: 2022 Cardinals MLB Game 116 thread – Wednesday, August 17 vs. Rockies #196025I comment on Montgomery often. Eddie is by far my favorite Cardinal. He is a treasure.
August 17, 2022 at 2:54 pm in reply to: 2022 Cardinals MLB Game 116 thread – Wednesday, August 17 vs. Rockies #196020Eddie has a 4.6 WAR only behind PG & NA(both 6.1) and he has the 8th best WAR among NL position players.
August 17, 2022 at 2:25 pm in reply to: 2022 Cardinals MLB Game 116 thread – Wednesday, August 17 vs. Rockies #196017Edman is the 3rd best Cardinal after Goldschmidt and Arenado.
August 17, 2022 at 10:53 am in reply to: 2022 Cardinals MLB Game 116 thread – Wednesday, August 17 vs. Rockies #195990Gorman won’t play 2B he will likely DH. Edman will play 2B as always should.
August 16, 2022 at 10:45 pm in reply to: 2022 Cardinals MLB Game 115 thread – Tuesday, August 16 vs. Rockies #195957Just be happy we won.
Gorman should be moved to a corner outfield and there is no reason not to do it.
Edman has only batted second 4 times this year. No conclusion can be drawn from 4 appearances.
I do not care if I convince anyone and I do not care what the numbers say. I am 73 years old and have played, coached and watched baseball all my life. Tommy Edman would bat second if I were making out the line-up.
Edman should bat # 2 IMO.
Edman has not hit second much, mostly lead-off and 9th. I don’t care about the recent numbers that IMO is his and the Cardinal’s best spot.
I like Tommy in the lien-up as the #2 hitter in front of Goldy.
I would be fine with that.
Winn should never play before Edman.
Edman should start at 2B every day over Gorman. Gorman is a bat first…wherever he plays is secondary.
“As I noted there are three corner OF prospects very close to MLB right now (all in our top 15 prospects) plus the four incumbents (O’Neill, Carlson, Nootbaar, Yepez). That is seven guys for three positions and at most two bench spots”.
Yepez isn’t an outfielder IMO…he is a DH/1B.
O’Neill is injured a lot.
In 2023, Burleson should be in St. Louis and can DH or play corner outfield.
Walker will be at Memphis at the start of 2023 and could transition to St. Louis early in the year and play RF.
That leaves Carlson in CF, Walker in RF, Burleson as a DH/LF and Nootbaar as a 4th outfielder.
Move Nolan Gorman to LF, with Carlson-CF, Walker-RF as the starters.
Edman is the starter at 2B but can also start at SS
DeJong is the starting SS.
Donavan is a utility infielder that can also play OF.
Gorman can be a back-up at 3B, 2B or DH. He is there for his bat first.
Moises Gomez is an option at DH/OF.If Gorman can learn 2B he can adapt to corner outfield just like Walker can. Edman can start at SS or 2B. Gorman can start in LF and be a backup at 3B & 2B & DH.
Next year the Cardinal’s 13-man position players:
C-Contreras
1B-Goldy
2B-Edman
SS-DeJong
3B-Arenado
LF-Gorman
CF-Carlson
RF-Walker
DH-Burleson vs LH/Yepez RH
Donavan- Utility player primarily on the infield.
Knizner or Herrara-back-up catcher
Nootbar or Gomez-back-up OFThe line-up that I posted obviously was not for this year. It also assumes O’Neill gets traded. I like O’Neill and I am for keeping him but think that the Cardinals probably move him. He is injured an awful lot. Gorman is an LH power hitter and would fit in well as a corner OF’er. Walker seems to me to an RF’er.
Do not trade Carlson, a switch hitter. O’Neill can be replaced by Gorman or Walker.
Line-up=
C-Contreras
1B-Goldy
2B-Edman
SS-DeJong
3B-Arenado
LF-Gorman
CF-Carlson
RF-Walker
DH-Burleson vs LH/Yepez RHWe should sign Wilson Contreras.
They both can be good.
but somebody might.
August 14, 2022 at 6:09 pm in reply to: 2022 Cardinals MLB Game 115 thread – Tuesday, August 16 vs. Rockies #195582The Cardinals have more talent than the Brewers. We will win the Central…it was won when we got Monty & Q and the Brewers traded Hader.
He isn’t going to…quit trying to buy trouble.
-
AuthorPosts
