Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Wow, I had to step away from the TV. What a finish!
Haha on Marsh. He was made for October. Not necessarily Mr October, but maybe Mr Fright. Mr Muchlinski ain’t scared of him though, he jobbed him pretty good.
Yea 1td, not having a rooting interest does have its advantages. You can thank Oli for that! Of course, I really think Mo deserves the lion’s share of the bla…..thanks.
Although I care next to nothing who wins, I am surprised I’ve still gotten frustrated when players don’t come through. It’s things like Jung striking out and not driving in a run in the 8th for Texas today — or like those DBacks’ base running mistakes last night, even though they still won.
Rangers aren’t going away yet, 1st two batters single to start the 9th
That’s how you give it away. Atta boy, Rangers.
To get nothing out of that inning is a bad omen for Texas. Jung’s AB was a big fail.
HPB and 3 ejections. Juices flowing.
DBacks win despite a couple late-inning base-running blunders.
Yep, he’s 3 years younger than Wainwright. He was elite into his mid-30s.
Hey, I’m 64 now and have noticed in each decade my body degrades about 2 or 3 times the rate as the previous decade. Kind of like compound interest. And I’m relatively healthy and active. It’s so nice to have the death train headed on a collision course with yourself moving at an exponentially increasing speed.
Scherzer still has the attitude of a bull terrier, just not the same bite as the 2012-2019 versions.
1td, I know some of your tendencies and figured you’d say something like that about Wilson and the Mets!
And stlcard makes a good point about the D and pitching being intertwined, especially with the lack of power pitchers. Given that backdrop, it felt like early on it was a strategic mistake to sacrifice the OF defense for more slug, especially when the slug wasn’t all that sluggy.
The Amazing Mookie — what a name. We need a guy named Mookie. That might be better than a Manny — whatya think 1td?
And no gscott, it’s not that Mookie played multiple positions in some games. He played multiple positions during some plays. That’s how good he is. I bet he pulls off the hit-the-same-ball-you-pitched trick better than Bugs Bunny. Yep, I hope Mo is working on getting us a Mookie.
And timeout for trivia — who was “Mookie” named after? Talking about the nickname. Also, what is the 3-letter monogram (initials) of his legal name. No cheating here. Mo will never land a Mookie if you cheat. That’d be the one case where it’d be the poster’s fault instead of Mo’s.
gscottar, good questions. I’ve wondered the same. It makes you wonder what is behind the scenes with some of these decisions — kind of like Gallen’s suspicion the Cards moved him because he didn’t attend a voluntary offseason camp.
Some people really believe Arozarena’s fate was sealed with his infamous locker room livestream. Sometimes behavior off the diamond matters, but I doubt that was the sole reason because he hadn’t received the reps I thought he should get even prior to the livestream.
I wonder if we should give the guy with the highest OBP the title of Plate Appearance Champion? And would that guy boast about it? Darn sure he would during next contract negotiation, hehe.
The SDI is 25% of the GG scoring.
Rat is probably right. I read something in the last couple years that said, while the SDI is just 25% mathematically, its real impact is probably much larger. It said the voters see the SDI numbers included on the “ballot” info (not sure if it’s paper or electronic) and that would have some influence on how they might vote. I think that makes sense.
Yep, and silver slugger has been around for quite a while.
It’s funny how the focus in this thread is….hmmm……evolving?
Philly has too much danger in its lineup for the DBacks.
The second tater might have been smoked instead of baked.
1td, I agree with that.
Don’t forget the trade involving Scott Rolen, Placido Polanco,Bud Smith, et al.
Always liked Sosa. I was always sort of a Phillies fan.
I never liked the Phils, but like Trea Turner a lot. He’d be fun to watch everyday in a Cardinals uniform.
Turner taters Kelly 1st inning.
Regarding waivers, I believe my prior comment to be accurate. Here are the rules. There are different kinds of waivers and the specifics can vary by time of the year, so it can be complicated. I think that Number 1 applies in this case.
Once secured, Outright Assignment Waivers remain in effect for a set period of time:
1. Seven days or until the end of the waiver period (whichever comes first) for Outright Assignment Waivers secured September 1st through the 30th day of the MLB regular season.
2. The entire waiver period for Outright Assignment Waivers secured starting on the 31st day of the MLB regular season through August 31st.
3. 72 hours if the player is on Optional Assignment to the minors or on a Disabled List.
Brian, your understanding is off because you are quoting info on the “waiver period,” and not the “claiming period.” Those rules are not relevant to what we were talking about. We were talking about the claiming period — which is a 47-hour window.
The waiver period rules you posted are relevant for an approved, “secured” waiver. The “securing” or “granting” of a waiver doesn’t happen until after the player clears waivers. Remember what a waiver is. It is permission granted for certain assignments of player contracts (such as for Garcia to fulfill his contractual obligations in AAA) or for the unconditional release of a player.
Just look at the waiver period in your item number 2. That’s a period of about 120 days during the regular season. Teams certainly don’t have 120 days to claim a player off waivers during the regular season. But once the waiver is secured, the team who obtained the waiver does have a 120-day waiver period to play the guy in AAA.
I believe 2 days versus 7 days to make a claim could very well make a meaningful difference — depends on the specific transaction. But yeah, teams will have to rely on scouting reports that are most likely a bit dated and most GMs are not going to pull the trigger with that uncertainty in a tight window on most players. Anyway, the info I am providing is available off the MLBPA site of rules for the CBA and MLB Rules on contractual matters. Here is an excerpt on the claiming period:
(3) Claiming Period. The period in which a Club may claim a
player on whom waivers have been sought is as follows:(A) Spring Training/In-Season Waivers. Except as provided for in Rule 8(b)(3)(B), the period in which a Club may claim a player on whom waivers have been sought is as follows:
Waivers Requested by ————— Waiver Claim Must Be
2:00 p.m. ————————– Entered by
Eastern Time on:—————– 1:00 p.m. Eastern Time on:
Monday ——————————– Wednesday
Tuesday ——————————- Thursday
Wednesday —————————– Friday
Thursday —————————— Saturday
Friday ——————————– Sunday
Saturday —————————— Monday
Sunday ——————————– Tuesday(B) Off-Season and End-of-Spring Training Waivers. When
waivers are requested during the periods set forth in Rules
8(b)(1)(B) and 8(b)(1)(C), the period in which a Club may claim a player on whom waivers have been sought is as follows:Waivers Requested by ————— Waiver Claim Must Be
2:00 p.m. ————————– Entered by
Eastern Time on:—————– 1:00 p.m. Eastern Time on:
Monday ——————————– Wednesday
Tuesday ——————————- Thursday
Wednesday —————————– Friday
Thursday —————————— Monday
Friday ——————————– TuesdayLastly, here is an excerpt on the rules you posted (waiver period). It’s not exactly as you posted, so maybe somethings were paraphrased by your source.
(4) Grant of Waivers and Effective Periods. In the event no claims are made before the deadline, waivers of the type requested are obtained, and the Commissioner or the Commissioner’s designee shall so notify the requesting Club. Outright assignment waivers obtained between September 1 and the 30th day of the following championship season (as determined by the first scheduled championship season game, excluding international openers), inclusive, shall be in effect until 1:00 p.m. Eastern Time on the seventh day after the date they were obtained, or until 5:00 p.m. Eastern Time on the 30th day of the championship season, whichever comes first. Outright assignment waivers obtained on and after the 31st day of the championship season shall be in effect until one hour following the Major League Trade Deadline described in Rule 6(d)(3); and outright assignment waivers obtained after the Major League Trade Deadline shall be in effect until midnight, Eastern Time on August 31, inclusive.
All teams scout every organization, especially the higher levels, and have reports on every player precisely for occasions such as these when a quick call has to be made. It would be a mistake to suggest Garcia was an unknown. There was “a book” on him at the time.
Obviously teams have “a book” on the several hundred players you refer to. Stale books for sure. How much in the way of recent active scouting do you think the other teams had done on Garcia over the last few season prior to his DFA? To suggest many teams are actively scouting guys like Garcia on a continuous basis is a mistake. I wasn’t suggesting Garcia was an unknown, just that teams aren’t usually postured to make a move on a very short turn for players with little recent in-depth scouting and thought to be marginal by the very fact they are being waived. It’s why the vast majority of outright/release waivers go unclaimed.
P.S. Waivers are seven days.
This is wrong. I was remembering 3 days, but after checking I found it to be 2 days, or 47 hours to be precise. The MLB waiver list is updated at 2PM each business day and the waiver claim/clearing is decided for a particular player at 1PM two days later.
Jnevel, I don’t agree with some of your statements.
The why did he get better with the Rangers and not us argument. Although it did take him 3 more seasons to get there.
It didn’t take him 3 more seasons. 2020 was not a season. His first real season with the Rangers was pretty darn good. You said he was an All-Star now, but he was also an All-Star in 2021. He was a member of the AL All-Star team in his rookie season and was 4th for the Rookie of the Year Award and had 3.7 WAR. He had about the same WAR in 2022 and then even better this year. So Garcia has had nothing but good seasons for the Rangers.
The next area is where you laid out a recurring theme of Garcia being a poor defender. For example, in 2021 you said he played “fairly bad defense.” For 2022 you said he played “fairly bad defense” and was “not great because of the defensive limitations.” And about 2023 you said “he still plays poor defense.”
Your take here baffles me. The Rangers think Garcia is about the best RFer in MLB and some of the stats support that. If the Gold Glove were determined solely by the SABR Defense Index, Garcia would be the winner of the AL Right Field GG this year based on the latest data. Of course voting is also part of the criteria. He is 1st for RFers and 5th overall for all defenders.
For the combined 2021 thru 2023 seasons, Garcia is 3rd in all of MLB for Defensive Runs Saved among RFers, even ahead of Mookie Betts, even though Betts has played more games than Garcia in RF (DRS is a counting stat). He is 4 behind Tucker (27 to 23) in DRS, but Tucker has played more games in RF (423 to 268) during these 3 seasons. So on a rate basis, Garcia would be 2nd overall. He was 1st in 2021 in DRS and his defensive play has been consistently good.
If you want to go by UZR over those 3 seasons, Garcia is 2nd in MLB for RFers (behind Mookie Betts). When I looked at the two competing overall defensive stats (UZR and DRS) in aggregate, it looks to me like Garcia scores better (more consistently high in both) than any of the other RFers in MLB.
I was not aware that Garcia was thought of as such a bad defensive prospect. All I had read was he had a plus arm. So if (like you said) he was considered by the Cards as “by far the worst defender” among Thomas, Carlson, Arozarena, and O’Neill, when he is actually one of the top RFers in MLB, it just adds to what became obviously clear in 2023. The Cards have some people in key decision making positions who don’t know didley about OF defense.
-
AuthorPosts
