Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Hey Steve, 1td and gscott. How about Helsley and one of our two untouchable prospects for Burnes, lol!
The nature of the arb process makes it a very tactical one. If I were a party to it, I couldn’t help but do a lot of 2nd guessing afterwards. I’ve known this all along, but this discussion has highlighted some possible real world outcomes.
Take Tucker’s case linked above. Astros offered 5, Tucker wanted 7.5. Say the arbiters thought his real value was 6.1, so they side with the Astros as the “better” of the two submissions. Then Tucker could speculate that if he had been just slightly less aggressive, he might’ve won. If he had requested 7, he would have won under the simple case I stated above, thus costing himself $2 million. Or turn it around and the team could say had we been $500K more generous with our offer, we could’ve come out $2 million better.
Organizations that melt to “public opinion” just because it’s public opinion are not doing it right. Public opinion is not always right. My part of public opinion is the Brewers did right in that they followed what both sides have agreed to for years and Burnes is being a sore loser (again not really if he was just doing a reactionary venting, but yes if he truly carries a grudge because he over-evaluated himself). I’ve read quite a few opinions that think Burnes is being wimpy. What is the real public opinion?
Here’s a different approach from Kyle Tucker, who had a $2.5MM delta between his and the Astros’ submission.
“The outcome wasn’t what we were hoping,” he said. “I don’t think it was the right one, but it is what it is at this point. I just wanted to go out there and fight for what my value was and what we kind of wanted to do. You’ve just got to respect it and move on and work on getting ready for the season.”
https://www.mlb.com/news/kyle-tucker-ready-to-move-on-after-loss-in-arbitration
Just looked and Corbin was the only arb case for the Brewers. Here is how that compares to other teams.
10 teams filed 0 cases
11 teams filed 1 case
5 teams filed 2 cases
1 team filed 3 cases
2 teams filed 4 cases
1 team filed 6 casesHard to see how the Brewers were trying to make a statement with that spread. Looks like a simple matter of the Brewers thought they had more accurately assessed Burnes’ value and they arbiters agreed.
However, I’m simply lending the perspective of someone who isn’t a member of the nobility…I like to imagine that if someone laid $10.7 MM on a picnic table, I’d leave $700,000 as a gratuity and get the heck out of there…Haha!
Hear, hear to that.
Plus it’s not like the Brewers were nefarious or cheap as you hear it often described. They went through a negotiated, agreed upon process that the players have benefitted from by millions for decades. Win some, lose some. Players now can whine about not getting over market value? Did Burnes expect the Brewers to present his case for him and say nothing but great things about him? Boohoo.
Do you also find it strange that Burnes should take such a confrontational approach to such a small amount?
This could be just a case of Burnes having an initial vent, then all parties move forward with a good season and don’t look back. If that happens, then all he did was release some frustration of the moment. Nothing really terrible with that.
If, however, he carries a grudge all season and keeps kicking dirt, then I’ll consider him extremely delicate. Nothing strange about that. There are a lot of delicate types nowadays.
Good point, forsch. Being in one zone with four teams in it could be worse than straddling two zones and being caught in both.
I’m in a great zone with the O’s and Nats because most years neither team does much for me, although pre-covid I used to drive there occasionally to watch other teams that interest me. Not because of covid now, but it just got me out of the groove of going. This year, Cards play 3 at each so I’ll probably go back again.
I guess he can always change his mind, so no loss either way for himself. Maybe the logic is if teams “know” he is committed to opting out, they will plan to secure/retain the enormous pile of dry powder needed to sign him.
On the other hand, I believe the number of games carried by Extra Innings depends on the provider and area.
Brian, that’s what I think, it might vary by provider. Luckily for me, I get every game. The caution to ZTR is he still won’t get “EVERY” game with MLB.tv, which is what I think he was getting at. The exclusive broadcasts, e.g., Apple TV, and the regional blackout games will still apply to MLB.tv just like they do to Extra Innings.
ZTR, just curious, did you also get MLB.tv login credentials as part of your subscription to Extra Innings? That’s handy to have.
It works both ways. That’s what you sign up for when you go to arbitration. Burnes can cut his nose off to spite his face, but is that professional? If he carries a grudge, pouts all year long and has a bad year, he’ll dwindle away his market value. Who wants to invest big in a guy like that?
“But when it came down to winning or losing the hearing, it was more than that for me.” Sure, pal. Big boys need to be big boys.
Edit and PS: just read your last post, 1td. Agree 100%.
I’d be interested to know the pct. of arb cases that are decided in favor of each side for the past 5 or so years and if there’s been any sort of detectable pattern. Anyone know?
Don’t know about your specific question, but read a while back that over the history of arbitration, the owners win more often, maybe close to 60-40. But the system has been a winner for even the players who lose their specific cases. The owners wouldn’t have been offering the salaries they do for non-free agent players if they weren’t bound to present something “reasonable” to the arbitrators.
Marvin Miller was a genius and played the owners…or got very lucky. To limit the supply of free agents entering the market in any given year like he did is a powerful economic force. Then getting arbitration for many of those not entering free agency was kind of like….eating your cake and having it too. Those were big wins from the very beginning. The system has remained top heavy though, favoring the good and very best. That’s not unlike all other sports and the entertainment industry in general.
The problem for me was that I must live on the edge of the Reds and Cardinals RSN zone line because sometimes a game would be blacked out / not shown on MLBEI because it was on Bally BUT, even though my tv guide would say that the Cards game was being broadcast on Bally – when I tuned to that channel it would be the Reds game.
How frustrating is this to be errantly impacted by TWO blackout zones? That would more than anything motivate me to go the VPN route to give MLB the finger.
For Brian and ZTR,
I haven’t experienced the same as you two evidently…or maybe I don’t understand what you’re saying. For instance, take the Apple TV game last year where Pujols hit 699 & 700 against the Dodgers. Are you saying you could stream those “Apple games” via MLB.tv? I didn’t think so and thought that game was exclusively through Apple. If so, my Extra Innings package shows every game that MLB.tv shows.
As I said earlier, what you get through Extra Innings might vary by provider. I believe that is the case because several years ago, Verizon in my area allotted about 8 or 10 high def channels (forget the exact number) for Extra Innings games. All remaining games would be on standard def channels. They were allotted by order of start time. Of course that put many Cards games on standard def since their games start later than most. West coast games were actually less likely to be on standard def than the Cards because the early high def games would be finished and freed up for the very late games. Eventually their were enough customer complaints that Verizon allotted enough High Def channels for all Extra Inning games. Great for Cards fans here.
Bottom line though is I get EVERY game for ALL MLB teams on Extra Innings except for exclusive broadcasts such as Apple TV, Youtube TV, etc., plus the O’s and Nats games because they are in my region. My understanding is those same exceptions are also true for MLB.tv everywhere, so no difference between Extra Innings and MLB.tv for me.
It’s not how much you make, it’s how much you keep. BDW wants to keep more of it.
1td, check under your sofa cushions.
Ryan Helsley sounds off
Corbin Burnes Expresses Disappointment
“It’s not personal….it’s strictly business.”
Brian, not sure if I understand the 2nd paragraph in your Extra Innings post. But I’ll describe for ZTR what I get with Extra Innings. If what we’re saying is inconsistent, it might be Extra Innings varies by provider.
I live in Virginia and get Extra Innings through Verizon Fios TV. The Nats and O’s are blacked out for me on Extra Innings, so I have to watch them on MASN, which also is part of my Verizon subscription. Extra Innings has been about $50 more per year than MLB.tv over the years. I prefer Extra Innings because I don’t have to stream it. It’s just another cable channel and has far superior recording, pausing, fast forwarding, replaying capabilities, etc. than streaming does. Also, it is much easier and faster to change channels on the cable set top box than it is to switch streams if you like to switch between games. I do that a lot, especially when the pennant races heat up. I also get all MLB games with Extra Innings — every game live, in HiDef, every day and night, so up to 15 games per day.
The other benefit is with Extra Innings I also get MLB.tv, so two for one. That way if I’m out shopping, dining, traveling a couple days to Mom’s, or whatever, I can watch the games via MLB.tv. I don’t rent a set top box in my exercise room TV, so if I want to watch a game while working out, I can stream it via MLB.tv. All of this is why Extra Innings is worth the extra $50 or so to me.
Still just IOS and Android support for MiLB game viewing.
Good to know. So as we discussed, watching on a TV monitor is limited to casting or TV web browser.
Jedi, I’m pretty sure (if I’m wrong, somebody please chime in) all that matters to invoke blackout on MLB.tv for you is your geographic location, as expressed by your Internet Protocol address. It doesn’t matter if you have 0, 1, or 20 alternatives at your specific residence to purchase the regional sports network, i.e., Bally. So, if you are in a Cardinal blackout location, either get Bally….or….connect to MLB.tv through a VPN. A VPN allows you to appear to be watching the game from somewhere other than your actual location.
February 16, 2023 at 4:54 pm in reply to: Former Cardinals in the News – 2017 to Aug. 2024 (closed) #212699I first really got into baseball in 1968. That’s why I’m a Redbird fan. What a memorable group of players and McCarver was a big part of all that. And isn’t our perception of time relative as the years go by? Hard to believe it’s been nearly two and a half years since Gibby and Lou passed away.
Announcing 101 with Professor Puggsley Addams
Is he on a sabbatical?
I am assuming that in order to watch the Cardinals on MLB.TV you have to live far enough away from St. Louis not to have to deal with the blackouts. Otherwise it is Bally or bust.
Yep, that’s a given…….or that VPN thingy. Thankfully I don’t have to deal with blackouts except when the Cards play the O’s or Nats. Even then I can watch on MASN.
Due to the cost increase and my decrease in interest of watching entire games, I’m not sure if I’ll buy up MLB.tv this year.
Probably not applicable to many, but I’ll throw this out there because the student discount for MLB.tv is significant. I’ve always kept account and login credentials at a couple of universities because it seemed like I was forever taking some kind of course for certification or professional development. That was good enough to get discounts and even free access to some Microsoft products, even while enrolled in just one course. Not sure if this would be the same for the MLB discount, but could be worth looking into if any of this applies for you this year or future years.
I am not aware of any smart TVs and streaming devices that MiLB supported previously.
Thanks for the dialogue. What you said is consistent with me not finding First Pitch on the app store for my Sony. And lol at me last night going down the same holes as you described, i.e., I also have a fire stick and roku device and couldn’t find the app for either one.
It is $129.99 to watch all of the Cardinal games. I will stream again this year…I got the e-mail from MLBTV today.
Yep, that’s the way to go if you only watch Cards’ games. It’s probably what I should do, cause now that I’m retired I often end up watching a West coast game after the Cards are done.
-
AuthorPosts
