- This topic has 616 replies, 22 voices, and was last updated 2 years, 4 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
As for going further, I believe we had a top 92 one year I was helping. So…we certainly have the knowledge here to go into extra innings.
I’m sure the powers that be (J. Nevel & cardsfan64) have been huddled in intent conversation as to just how far to extend this top prospect list. Do we do 55? 60? A most lofty total of 92, as stlcard25 proposed? Or the near unattainable 100, as LouisEu dangled out there? I think it would be nice if a decision were to be rendered before high noon tomorrow (Monday).
I would be willing to monitor the votes up to 60 if the group wishes, but will need to back out then due to holiday activities. Haven’t had any contact with jnevel to this point and will defer to him since he started this thread. Last three in our top 50 will be posted tonight! Still have a few regular voters that haven’t submitted their votes.
P.S. I have noticed that we are getting a wide spectrum of players with only one voter naming them on their ballot (10 this past vote so far). Seems like the farther out we get that there is no consensus. Might be a good reason to cap it at 60.Cards64, I agree. Capping it at 55 or 60 is probably best (60 is fine as you suggested). I think we could get around 80-85 prospects named if we wanted to but after that our other players truly are just filler with not much potential to ever be in the big leagues. We could also do like Brian and Blake and just name our “Best of the Rest”. To do that, we could run the normal vote to 50 (which ends tonight) and then each of us names 15 other prospects that we like who we considered for the top 50 (or we had in the top 50). Then, you can make a master sheet of how many times those guys got named in someone’s list to come up with our final Best of the Rest in no particular order. I can help count them up if you want. So either method works but I kind of prefer this Best of the Rest method because it gets hard at this point to rank guys in order.
I agree, Jnevel. Best of the rest works for me with the best 15 left after our top 50. What does everyone else think? We could probably go 48 hours to make sure everyone gets their choices in. I could then run a tally of how many times a player was named and post that to close us out.
I agree
15 names every voters
Probably we’ll have 25-30 names on the table
The 15 most voted are “the best of the rest”
it’s right?LouisEu,
As far as I understood jnevel, and my past experience of voting in this poll; we will include all votes but rank them by how many votes each player gets. So if Adari Grant is named on 10 ballots and Chris Rotando is listed 8 times, Grants name would be placed above Rotando on our “Best of the Rest” list. Each voter will list their top 15 choices, but we very well could have over 30 names mentioned. They will, however, be placed in order by how many ballots they are mentioned on.ok sounds good.
possibly a requirement of “at least two votes” could be put in place.
Just to avoid crazy names 🙂Love-17/ Church-16/ Rivas-15/ D Rodriguez-5/ Zuniga-4/ Harrison-4/ Komar-3/ Pino-3/ Cordoba-2/ Mills-2/ Marrero-2/ B Garcia-2/ S Hernandez-1/ O’Brien-1/ E Carrera-1
#48-Love
#49- Church
#50- Rivas
COMMUNITY TOP 50 PROSPECTS
1. Winn
2. Saggese
3. Hence
4. Roby
5. Scott
6. Hjerpe
7. Graceffo
8. McGreevey
9. Davis
10. Bernal
11. Rajcic
12. Robberse
13. Cho
14. Kloffenstein
15. Crooks
16. Showalter
17. Hansen
18. Bedell
19. Mautz
20. Honeyman
21. Rom
22. Pages
23. Baez
24. Prieto
25. Granillo
26. Nunez
27. Matthews
28. Antico
29. Levenson
30. Paniagua
31. Mejia
32. Rincon
33. Gómez
34. Cornwell
35. Svenson
36. Mendlinger
37. Koperniak
38. Baker
39. Redmond
40. Dunn
41. Fernandez
42. Willis
43. Iadisernia
44. Santos
45. Thomas
46. Siani
47. Yeager
48. Love
49. Church
50. RivasWe now have our complete Community 2024 Top 50 Prospects! Well done, everyone! In a few months, we will begin to see how our choices actually perform on the diamond!
It has been suggested that we continue with a “Best of the Rest” vote to add players that made our personal list but not the groups. Maybe you feel like some a player or players will take off this spring and put it all together and rise up the prospect list. The plan is to choose up to 15 additional players (in no particular order) and they will receive a tally for each voter that includes them in their list. On Tuesday evening, I will tally up the names and list them in order of tally marks.Chris Rotondo
Braden Jobert
Ixan Henderson
William Sullivan
Andrew Marrero
Sammy Hernandez
Zane Mills
Jake Buchberger
Jose Cordoba
Chris Worley
Luis Pino
Guillermo Zuniga
Mike Curialle
Osvaldo Tovalin
Adari GrantThanks cardsfan64 for finishing this up and putting together our final run on Best of the Rest.
Here’s my 15 others that I like who I feel are worth keeping an eye on:
Komar
Loutos
Zuniga
Loutos
O’Brien
Ynfante
Pereira
Sullivan
Rotondo
Marrero
Sawyer
Lin
Henderson
Dionys Rodriguez
WorleyHere are my 15 “Best of the Rest” choices.
Dionys Rodriguez
Jose Cordoba
Leonardo Taveras
Chris Rotondo
Chen-Wei Lin
Michael Curialle
Adari Grant
Guillermo Zuniga
Andrew Marrero
Benito Garcia
Ross Friedrick
William Sullivan
Kade Kretzschmar
Emisael Carrera
Wilfredo PereiraI am very satisfied with the good work we all did together.
Of our TOP 50, 44 are also in my personal ranking. I hadn’t included C.Thomas (dropped to my #51 for new arrivals), R.Fernandez, A.Iadisernia, RJ Yeager, N.Church and A.Love.So my 15 “best of rest” are primarily my six top50 not selected by the group and then the next nine:
J.Cordoba (my #40)
S.Hernandez (#43)
L.Sequera (#45)
J. King (#46)
K. Kretzschmar (#47)
J.Salazar (#49)
L.Rodriguez (the one from 2004)
J. Savacool
C. Harrison
I. Henderson
R. Garcia
T. Richardson
L. Pino
M.Curriale
B. KomarYes great effort everyone. Thanks to the worthies who led the effort this year.
For this last bunch, my first group are those from my matrix who did not make the list. Then I took another quick look at those mentioned by others and chose a group. And the final name is my ‘if you have a jersey, you have a chance’ group.
Charles Harrison
William Sullivan
Guillermo Zuniga
Riley O’Brien
Adari Grant
Zane Mills
Jason SavacoolKomar
Curialle
Cordoba
Salazar
Chen Wei Lin
Loutos
SawyerGrant Black
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.