- This topic has 620 replies, 37 voices, and was last updated 6 years ago by
.
-
Posts
-
Can you guarantee him all those moves you’re advocating will happen? How can you sell plans to a player without any confidence they can happen? On a side note are you even sure the Cardinals are considering all those moves you keep bringing up? He has the money he wants and the no trade clause he needs I don’t see him coming here. I hope he does and think the Marlins would make deal with the Cards.
My point was only that where a player prefers to go is not always where they end up and to me it’d be a waste of everyone’s time for the Marlins to take an offer from a team that there’s not a chance of Stanton going to…
New article from the Miami Herald beat writer:
“Marlins warn Stanton: Accept a trade or you’ll be only star on stripped-down team”
https://www.miamiherald.com/sports/spt-columns-blogs/fish-bytes/article186954163.html
A big question has no clear answer, per research by Eno Sarris.
David Ortiz, Jim Edmonds, Jorge Posada, Chipper Jones all played a similar amount of games per season before 28, and aged well. It’s hard to know how Giancarlo Stanton will age.
https://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/we-dont-really-know-how-giancarlo-stanton-will-age/
I cannot copy the full exchange here, but I have had a back and forth Stanton discussion on Twitter with my friend Craig Mish of SiriusXM.
Here is one nugget from Craig.
I asked a source yesterday if anything had changed w him accepting a deal to STL. Source said yes. I waited to confirm. Now I am not even sure if the yes was a “forced” yes or a real yes. So crazy.
Here are our Twitter feeds:
OK, I summarized tonight’s news on the Stanton trade rumors in an article. Please read it now, before it is out of date! (free)
https://thecardinalnation.com/are-the-cardinals-chances-increasing-in-stanton-trade-talks/
Former GM Steve Phillips makes an interesting observation.
That’s a bluff that is worth calling if you are Stanton. The #Marlins need to move him more than he needs to be moved. Miami can trade everyone else around him but in the end they will move him where he wants to go too. #power
https://twitter.com/StevePhillipsGM/status/935678805636763649
If Stanton does call their bluff and Jeter does not seem the type to go back on his word he is sure going to enjoy losing 100+ games in Miami and if he is ok with that then he needs to do what he needs to do, but Miami is not going to give him away just so he can go where he wants that would literally kill their franchise.
Yes, both sides have leverage in what is a very complex situation. That is why I was not surprised when some estimated a trade would not get done quickly. There is a lot at stake for both parties.
Problem is nothing else is getting done because of this it seems either. When / if this finally gets resolved there are going to be a lot of domino’s fall in a short amount of time…just hoping Cards have a backup plan in place other than throw trash at the wall to hope it sticks.
My guess is that Mo and company have given or will give Miami a deadline for this to be resolved. Most likely the start of the Winter meetings
Oh gscottar you have talked to Stanton personally?
If not stop with the garbage of him going to dodgers or staying in Miami and posting it as facts!
Because lets face it if they want a big power bat, Staton is plan A, B C and D!
The Dodgers are already over the luxury tax. It would cost them 50M for 2018 alone to acquire Stanton. Everybody has limitations whether they are aware of those limitations, or not.
Oh gscottar you have talked to Stanton personally?
If not stop with the garbage of him going to dodgers or staying in Miami and posting it as facts!
Because lets face it if they want a big power bat, Staton is plan A, B C and D!
I’ve heard too many insiders state what his preferences are. I suppose he could pull a Verlander and change his mind at the last minute but I wouldn’t count on it.
It doesn’t matter if the Cards want Stanton or not. It doesn’t matter if the Marlins like what the Cards are offering. Stanton has all of the leverage here.
The Dodgers are already over the luxury tax. It would cost them 50M for 2018 alone to acquire Stanton. Everybody has limitations whether they are aware of those limitations, or not.
The Dodgers have at least $60M coming off the books after 2018 so if they are really worried about the luxury tax they could tell Stanton to sit tight one more year and they will trade for him next winter.
He doesn’t want to play for a loser so staying in Miami to be on the very worst team in all of baseball prob doesn’t sit well with him…he can be traded to a winner and play for 3 years and then opt out and go to Dodgers if he wants…
Your love affair with him going to the dodgers is comical at best.
You seem pretty sure that it will be the Cardinals…but just in case he decides against coming here…what would be your guess of an alternate destination? I know you think this is all but a done deal but maybe Boston? Giants? Yankees?
So far there seems to be only three choices for him, a trade to the Giants and have the team go into a full rebuilding mode which is something that he’s said that he doesn’t want to do, stay in Miami and play for a terrible team that is rebuilding which is also something that he’s said that he doesn’t want to do, or be traded to St Louis and play for a team that barely missed the playoffs and is probably only a few trades and free agents away from being good to great…
As for the opt out, or he could come here, love it and decide to stay…
Seems that the Giants are thinking of McCutcheon of the Pirates as a fallback guy in case they don’t get Stanton…
Casey Stern is adamant Stanton will not go to St. Louis and suggest he holds the cards when it comes to him being moved. https://twitter.com/MLBNetworkRadio/status/935955532334157825
I guess he doesn’t think Miami would be willing to fire sell the rest of the team and would move Stanton regardless.
Matt Holliday says he would call Giancarlo Stanton to sell him on St. Louis if needed. (2 minute clip)
https://twitter.com/MLBNetworkRadio/status/936008259655348225
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.