Minor league thread – Wed 7/31

Home › The Cardinal Nation Forums › Open Forum › Minor league thread – Wed 7/31

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 38 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #100053
    Brian Walton
    Keymaster

    Paid - Annual

    Memphis vs. Albuquerque, 6:35 pm CT, Ryan Helsley (2-3, 4.98)
    Springfield off
    Palm Beach at St. Lucie, 6:30 pm ET, Diego Cordero (1-3, 3.00)
    Peoria vs. Kane County, 6:35 pm CT, Connor Thomas (2-0, 2.00)
    State College vs. Vermont, 7:05 pm ET, Enmanuel Solano (1-5, 4.47)
    Johnson City at Princeton, 6:30 pm ET, Luis Ortiz (0-0, 4.50)
    GCL Cards off
    DSL Blue at Phillies Red, 10:30 am ET, Gustavo J Rodriguez (3-0, 1.13)
    DSL Red vs. Cubs2, 10:30 am ET, Yonael Dominguez (1-0, 3.65) or Angel Cuenca (4-1, 1.65)

    #100260
    BlackHillsCard
    Participant

    Free

    Going back to the Cardinals jerking Helsley around, he pitches 3 innings but they pull him after just 35 pitches in a game he was dominating. He threw 48 pitches last start. They aren’t even trying to build his arm strength up.

    #100279
    Brian Walton
    Keymaster

    Paid - Annual

    I wasn’t watching the feed, but it suggests to me perhaps there is an injury concern. No reason if healthy to reduce his pitch count while starting every fifth day. On the other hand, it he starts pitching more frequently, that suggests a relief role.

    As far as pitch counts over time, he was moved to relief, was with StL in that role and went on the IL. When he came back, he started in the 20s then worked up to the 30s then 40s.

    Without understanding what is going on with his shoulder, the “jerked around” argument is only a theory.

    I get that some on social media think the people in the organization are much less intelligent than them. On the other hand, I know these people and I have zero reason to suspect they would limit the development of one of their best pitching prospects for what are undefined theories.

    P.S. I want to correct my time point. He hadn’t pitched in six days. (And he was not sharp overall the prior time out. I watched that start on the 25th.)

    #100281
    Cardinals27
    Participant

    Free

    Wth is wrong with letting Helsley pitch longer? 3 perfect innings, 35 pitches, why not let him pitch longer? We need a starter or 2. Is the FO determined Helsley can’t be a starter? We could use some evaluators and managers that don’t have closed minds. I am pissed.

    #100283
    BlackHillsCard
    Participant

    Free

    It wouldn’t be the first time the Cardinals have ruined and/or stagnated the development of a prospect. See Carson Kelly.

    #100286
    Brian Walton
    Keymaster

    Paid - Annual

    Sorry, but I can see no relevance of catcher Kelly to pitcher Helsley.

    #100305
    Cardinals27
    Participant

    Free

    I would like to a piece of optimism today from the idiots in charge.

    #100318
    Brian Walton
    Keymaster

    Paid - Annual

    I checked and Helsley is not injured, he is being kept in a relief role, but getting his relief work done early in the game. As mentioned before, whether it is the first through third vs. fourth through sixth, matters none.

    #100323
    Cardinals27
    Participant

    Free

    Brilliant. I think less of those in charge. Woodford got lit up his last start. Cabrera is clearly not ready for a starters role yet. Who is the 6th starter as of now? I am glad we have such great insurance.

    #100324
    BlackHillsCard
    Participant

    Free

    That’s your take, Brian. I, and others, have a different take.

    #100325
    Cardinals27
    Participant

    Free

    I am thinking of joining the camp of changing front office personnel. Probably won’t happen though.

    #100326
    Brian Walton
    Keymaster

    Paid - Annual

    They are not jerking him around. They made him a long reliever some months ago and are pitching him roughly every fifth day. I was misled because he was the first pitcher of the game the last couple times out. In reality, him pitching early is more of a reflection of the mess that is the Memphis rotation (three starters injured).

    You can certainly disagree with the decision, but why not provide some details to support your point then? Anyone can make vague complaints.

    #100328
    BlackHillsCard
    Participant

    Free

    Whatever, Brian. I’m not the only one who sees they are jerking him around.

    He was a starter at the beginning of the season and now he’s just a reliever? That makes no sense. What also doesn’t make sense is if he’s going to be a reliever, why do they keep having him start games? As a reliever he should see different scenarios so he is comfortable when he get brought up. Always being put in the same situation and scenario is stupid and does nothing for his development if you want to use him in relief. But then again, anyone can stand by and defend this organization even when they don’t deserve it.

    #100332
    Brian Walton
    Keymaster

    Paid - Annual

    If one agreed with the “the different situations are better” logic, then one should like how he is being used. Here are his Memphis appearances since coming back from his injury.

    6/26 8th inning
    6/29 7th inning
    7/1 3rd inning
    7/6 8th-9th inning
    7/11 8th-9th inning
    7/15 4th-6th inning
    7/25 1st-3rd inning
    7/31 1st-3rd inning

    Summary: In eight appearances, he has thrown in every inning, but in any one specific inning no more than three times. (Most often in the 3rd and 8th innings.) He “started” just twice.

    So, is this changing spots in the game good for his development or “jerking him around”? I am confused.

    #100368
    Cardinals27
    Participant

    Free

    Long relief is such a preferred and distinguishing role for a top 5 prospect. Between that and Fernandez’s usage makes me think this is teeball, and time must be spent equally. You have to give the lesser prospects equal chance.

    #100370
    Cardinals27
    Participant

    Free

    Can anyone name me a top 5 prospect in long relief at the minor league level? Perhaps rehabbing. But that is not the case here….

    #100374
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    If they are going to pitch him only every 5 or 6 days, why not make him a starter? It seems crazy to call him a middle reliever, have him be the first pitcher, pitch only every 5 days and throw less than 50 pitches. I must be missing something.

    #100383
    Brian Walton
    Keymaster

    Paid - Annual

    Returning to starting is a fair question and I don’t know for sure why not given the team’s need for starting help. One logical explanation I can think of would be his shoulder. Will dig around a bit.

    Ironically, another possible explanation to not make him a real starter again is that they don’t want to “jerk him around”.

    Those critical of his usage cite his being changed from starting to relieving and back and forth as a prime example of him being “jerked around”. They say the Cards should decide one role and stop changing him back and forth.

    The reality is that the team did precisely that. There was only one move this season – from starting at the beginning of the year to relief shortly after and they have stayed with that since.

    One flaw in the “jerked around” logic was shown above. He may have been the first pitcher in two recent games, but his actual usage has been consistent as a long reliever, albeit in different points in the game (which we were told here is good for his development).

    My summary of two separate concerns being stated:
    “Why is he not starting?” A fair question. No clear answer yet.
    “Why is he being jerked around? No evidence of this at all.

    #100390
    Brian Walton
    Keymaster

    Paid - Annual

    #100401
    forsch31
    Participant

    Free

    I am starting to wish there was an easy way to get Arozarena starting in the majors. If he can hit around .300 in the majors and maintain his minor league contact and slugging rates, he could be a valuable spark plug for the team.

    The thought that we have Carlson, Arozarena, Thomas and O’Neill makes me wonder how we can use them. Between needing some for the major league team and using some for trades, I hope they all provide the Cardinals with great returns. Then there is Torres, Fletcher, Garcia and Capel, as well. All that leaves out Bader who has already provided value to the major league team but needs to re-discover his hitting stroke.

    This all leaves a dilemma on whether or not to re-sign Ozuna.

    #100409
    Brian Walton
    Keymaster

    Paid - Annual

    Not sure about all the rest, but the last part is fairly clear to me. My reading is that Ozuna isn’t likely coming back for 2020.

    #100414
    stlcard25
    Participant

    I agree with Brian. Ozuna seems to be a foregone goner with a QO attached barring something very odd. The Cards will take their sweet sandwich pick and move on. Given all the potential talent waiting in the wings, they simply must let a couple of them have a shot or use them in bigger trades. The Fowler deal really almost forces that from a payroll standpoint.

    #100430
    gscottar
    Participant

    Paid - Annual

    I have said all along that Ozuna shouldn’t and most likely wouldn’t come back for 2020.

    Forsch, you cited all of the OF’s in the system and mentioned that some could be used for trades. While that is still true in theory I am still in disbelief that it didn’t happen yesterday. That is a stunner for me so I am beginning to wonder if any of those guys will ever be traded.

    #100452
    BlackHillsCard
    Participant

    Free

    Garcia is a AAAA player at best.

    Fletcher is years away from St. Louis. After tearing up the GCL he’s been shut down in the Appy.

    Capel, Pinder, and Hurst have all taken steps back this season.

    Torres is having an okay season at Johnson City but its nothing to write home about, but the power appears promising.

    If you’re going to call up Thomas, use him. I don’t understand calling up an actual outfielder like Thomas and then using Munoz as a defensive replacement while Thomas sits.

    #100454
    14NyquisT
    Participant

    As far as the organization trying to use young pitchers in different situations up and down and then back again, Mike O’Reilly comes to mind. He was pitching very well as a starter… then moved all the way up to Memphis and into the bullpen. Results were horrible and were is he today. I know that he was ONLY a 27th rd. pick in ’16 but for the ’17 season he was grabbing A LOT of attention and had the time of his life.

    I don’t know if he was “jerked around” by the organization, but he went from GCL to AAA Memphis in two seasons. Why did they never gave him another chance to start again where he was successful.

    (no trips to the DL)

    2016 GCL

    2017 up to PEO 9-2 1.75 ERA 15-g 12-gs 0.65 WHIP (STARTER)
    2017 up to PB– 3-1 3.29 9-g 9-gs 1.35-WHIP (STARTER)

    Beginning of ’18 TCN’s #33 prospect

    2018 4/24 up to SPFD 3-6 5.32 13-g 13-gs 1.44-WHIP (STARTER)
    2018 5/6 up to MEM 0-1 5.84 6-g 0-gs 1.38-WHIP (RELIEF)
    2018 6/4 back down to SPFD
    2018 8/1 down to
    PB 2-1 3.21 13-g 2-gs (RELIEF)

    2019 4/3 assigned to SC
    2019 4/12 up to SPFD 0-1 7.94 5-g 0-gs 1.50-WHIP (RELIEF)
    2019 4/30 Released

    I’ll let you, the reader, decide if the organization failed O’Reilly. He might have just walked out and stayed away from the game. SAD TALE

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 38 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

First-hand news and commentary on the St. Louis Cardinals™ and minor league system for over 25 years