Setting My St. Louis Cardinals All-Time Draft List

photo: Ted Simmons (Getty Images)

As introduced in an earlier article, this weekend I am participating in a mock draft of the best all-time St. Louis Cardinals players with my friends at Rotowire. Over at The Cardinal Nation’s free message board, a number of readers have offered their recommendations on how I could maximize my results.

My approach

The draft guidelines are intentionally vague, as the exercise is just for fun. Rosters will not be run through a simulator covering a season or a group of them. Given that, and within the need to build a balanced roster by position, I selected career WAR as a Cardinal as my primary measure. As many readers know, there are several WAR formulas, leading to slightly different results. Since the Cardinals Hall of Fame uses the Baseball Reference version, so am I. Results should not vary substantially, either way.

As a secondary indicator, I logged how many seasons each player spent with the team. If my decision between two players needed a tiebreaker, I would probably lean toward the one who had the higher per season production.

Generally, I did not include those on my draft list with under 10 bWAR as a Cardinal, though I had to make an exception. Relief pitchers do not fare well on the WAR scale, so to include every Cardinals Hall of Famer, I had to lower my standard.

Bruce Sutter

In his four seasons with St. Louis, Hall of Famer and the man who wore retired number 42, Bruce Sutter, delivered four bWAR. That presented me with a dilemma. Our rules only state that six pitchers must be selected. No breakdown between starters and relievers was dictated.

So, do I show respect for the bullpenners by including at least one of them, or do I go for the top six pitchers in Cardinals career WAR, knowing in advance that they will all be starters?

I included six of the best relievers on my candidate list, but I am going to wait to see how the draft goes in comparing the three drafted teams in total Cardinals WAR. If I can stay on top with a reliever, I will probably join in.

My draft list

Below are my positional lists to be used during the draft. Rosters include the normal eight starting position players plus a utilityman and six hurlers. The sequence is by position by total Cardinals bWAR.

Once the draft program is aired on the Rotowire Fantasy Sports Today show, from 1:00-3:00 p.m. ET on Sunday on SiriusXM Fantasy Radio, and the follow up article at is posted, I will be back with the rosters, career bWAR totals and commentary on my picks.

Pos Player StL yrs StL WAR Pos Player StL yrs StL WAR
1B Pujols 12 87 C T Simmons 13 45
Mize 6 39 Molina 16 40
Bottomley 11 34 Torre 6 23
Hernandez 10 34 McCarver 12 21
White 8 28 Pagnozzi 12 11
Konetchy 7 27 W Cooper 8 10
Collins 6 21
McGwire 5 19 P Player StL yrs StL WAR
Cunningham 7 16 Gibson 17 82
Comiskey 9 12 Dean 7 40
Cepeda 3 11 Brecheen 11 39
Wainwright 15 36
2B Player StL yrs StL WAR Haines 18 36
Hornsby 13 91 Lanier 12 30
Schoendienst 15 35 M Cooper 8 29
Frisch 11 33 Jackson 8 29
Huggins 7 19 King 3 29
Herr 10 19 C Carpenter 9 28
Wong 7 16 Pollet 9 28
Oquendo 10 15 Caruthers 5 26
Sherdel 14 25
3B Player StL yrs StL WAR Sallee 9 25
Boyer 11 58 Doak 13 24
M Carpenter 9 28 Forsch 15 21
Rolen 6 26 Carlton 7 21
Kurowski 9 25 Brazle 10 21
Martin 13 21 Broglio 6 20
Oberkfell 8 17 Tudor 5 20
Pendleton 7 15 Morris 8 19
C Simmons 7 19
SS Player StL yrs StL WAR Dickson 9 17
O Smith 15 66 Hallahan 10 17
Marion 11 31 Mizell 7 16
Hemus 9 22 Young 2 16
Templeton 6 19 Martinez 7 15
Renteria 6 17 Lynn 6 15
Alexander 4 15
OF Player StL yrs StL WAR Andujar 5 13
Musial 22 128 Magrane 6 12
Slaughter 13 52 Tewksbury 6 11
Brock 16 42 Hrabosky 8 7
Flood 12 42 Rosenthal 6 6
Medwick 11 40 Isringhausen 7 5
Edmonds 8 38 Worrell 6 5
Lankford 13 38 Sutter 4 4
McGee 13 26 L Smith 4 4
O’Neill 7 25
Holliday 8 23
Hafey 8 21
Moore 11 21
Jordan 7 20
Hendrick 7 18
Drew 6 18
Burkett 3 18
Blades 10 15
Coleman 6 12

Draft list observations

Not surprisingly, Stan Musial is on top, as the only triple-digit WAR player in team history. Next is Rogers Hornsby, Albert Pujols and Bob Gibson – hence the heads on my Cardinals Mt. Everest. No one is close to this top four.

Rogers Hornsby

As you may have noticed, each position’s WAR leader has a total that is roughly double compared to the number two player, if not more. The only substantial exception is catcher, at which there is only a five-WAR gap between Ted Simmons and Yadier Molina.

This distribution led me to try to secure the top performer at as many different positions as possible in my draft, therefore maximizing my total team WAR edge over the other two drafters. At least, this is the plan.

Bob Gibson

One byproduct is that I devalued pitching relatively speaking, but this decision was supported by a clustering of 14 pitchers between 20 and 29 bWAR. In all, 20 pitchers in Cardinals history logged at least 20 WAR, and only 18 will be taken in this entire draft. In other words, if I didn’t get Bob Gibson, I could wait to fill out my staff.

Another position at which I like the depth is first base, with seven players totaling at least 20 career WAR with St. Louis. And that does not include Musial, who I put in the outfield. One of these two positions is the likely source of my utility selection.

At the other end of the equation is the middle infield, with just three players at both second base and shortstop having accrued more than 20 career WAR. Again, three is the magic number as it represents the quantity of teams participating in this draft.

Among current Cardinals, Yadier Molina, Adam Wainwright and Matt Carpenter are likely to be chosen, with Kolten Wong and Carlos Martinez not far from consideration.

Related article

Drafting An All-Time St. Louis Cardinals Team

Bonus for members of The Cardinal Nation

Two St. Louis Cardinals Who May Benefit Most from MLB’s Delay

Now Available! – TCN’s New 2020 Prospect Guide

232 pages, 97,000 words, over 60 player capsules, history and much more – in both PDF and spiral-bound book versions. Foreword by Dan McLaughlin. Order your copy today!

Join The Cardinal Nation for in-depth coverage of the St. Louis Cardinals and their minor league system, continuing daily, even while play is suspended.

Brian Walton can be reached via email at or for fastest turnaround, pose your questions on The Cardinal Nation’s members-only forum. Follow Brian on Twitter.

© 2020 The Cardinal Nation, All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.