I’m not sure that Carpenter is that much better at third than he is at second. I guess the range is not as critical at third. He fumbles a lot of balls at third as well.
Carp just doesnt have a position. Someone said it in another thread. He is ideal in a 1b/dh/backup if role. He doesnt quite hit enough to justify 1b full time but he more than hits enough to play him everywhere.
/shrugs
Voit has impressed so far. Like I said let’s see how the adjustment phase goes.