Everyone healthy – what is your roster?

[CariocaCardinal]

Carpenter
Wong
Dejong
Gyrko
Molina
Pham
Ozuna
Fowler

Pena
Munoz
Bader
JMart

Wainwright
CMart
Flaherty
Mikolos
Wacha

Hicks
Reyes
Norris
Holland
Gregerson
Leone
Cecil
Lyons

Other pitchers are optioned.

This is what I think it would be. Still debating what I think it should be.

[Onyxgem]

Bader has to be started at very least in RF, but honestly as great defensively as he is he should be starting CF everyday

[stlcard25]

I’d probably have a standard starting lineup of:

1B Carp
SS Dejong
CF Pham
LF Ozuna
3B Gyorko
RF Bader
C Yadi
2B Wong

-Jmart gets a couple starts at 1B a week and maybe spots LF for Ozuna once
-Fowler gets 4 starts a week in RF (Bader spots for Pham one a week), LH PH
-Munoz backs up 3B-SS-2B
-Garcia backup, PH against RHP
-Peña backup C

1. Cmart
2. Wacha
3. Mikolas
4. Flaherty/Weaver
5. Reyes

Norris
Hicks
Leone
Lyons
Cecil
Waino
Gant

I realize Gregerson and Holland have to be in there but I don’t think I would trust them much even at full health. I’d like to be wrong come October.

[14NyquisT]

For now I’m leaving out Wainwright, Leone + Reyes (soon to be) who are on the 60 day DL.

With Molina, CMartinez and DeJong back:

CMartinez
Wacha
Mikolas
Flaherty
Weaver

Lyons L
Cecil L
Gomber L
Norris
Hicks
Gregerson
Holland
and one of Bowman-Brebbia-Tuivailala

Molina
Pena (bench)

Carpenter
Wong
DeJong
Gyorko
JoMartinez (bench)
GGarcia (bench)

Ozuna
Pham
Bader
O’Neill (bench)

Kelly has to be traded. He’s not going to sit in St Louis and isn’t hitting much AND there’s no room for him at Memphis with the emergence of Knizner.

Fowler has to be traded. He isn’t playing up to the team’s standards.

Cecil-Gregerson-Holland are in the same boat… become effective or move on.

We are STILL looking for a proven power bat for the cleanup spot. We have some chips and only a handful should be excluded for consideration.

[gscottar]

Trying to make a lineup out of this roster because some can only hit, some can only play defense, and some can only hit LH pitching, and most of the bullpen is ineffective, etc…. but my lineup would be:

2B Carp
CF Pham
SS DeJong
1B JMart
LF Ozuna
C Molina
3B Gyroko
RF Bader
P

Bench Pena
Bench Wong
Bench Fowler
Bench Munoz

SP CMart
SP Mikolas
SP Wacha
SP Flaherty
SP Weaver

RP Gomber
RP Lyons
RP Brebbia
RP Mayers
RP Tui
RP Holland
RP Hicks
RP Norris

I would DFA Cecil, Gregerson, and Garcia. Waino should stay on the DL the rest of the year and Reyes probably will as well. Bowman should be optioned to Memphis. I am hoping Holland will be more effective after a 30 day rehab.

[Author]

Posts