IMO, the numbers he posted through 2022, his last MVP year, are enough to merit him being in the HOF.
I disagree with 1td about Edmonds. Edmonds should be in the HOF. I think he rubbed some of the voters the wrong way so they didn’t vote for him. Some of the comments he made while broadcasting about how he would start running to where he thought the ball was going to go before the pitcher even released the pitch were mind blowing. He said he could tell by what kind of hitter was batting and the pitch that the pitcher was likely going to throw. Head case and a–hole, LaRussa, might have hurt him. also.
If Arenado somehow doesn’t get into the HOF, then the HOF should be eliminated entirely for being a ruse.