2010 – Zach Cox & Seth Blair
2011 – Kolten Wong & Charlie Tillson
2012 – Michael Wacha, James Ramsey, Stephen Piscotty, Patrick Wisdom, Steve Bean, Carson Kelly
2013 – Marco Gonzalez, Rob Kaminsky, and Oscar Mercado
2014 – Luke Weaver, Jack Flaherty, Ronnie Williams, and Andrew Morales
2015 – Nick Plummer, Jake Woodford, Bryce Denton
2016 – Delvin Perez, Dylan Carlson, Dakota Hudson, Connor Jones
2017 – 0
2018 – Nolan Gorman, Griffin Roberts, Luken Baker
2019 – Zack Thompson & Tre Fletcher
Zero stars so far in these picks. Wacha was really good for a short period. Gorman has a solid shot at getting there. Carlson has a very outside chance.
A lot of these guys got traded for other players so I’m not sure this is a perfect science. But Wong, Piscotty, Wacha, Hudson, and Flaherty probably hit the threshold you set and I think Carlson and Gorman will get there. Maybe Thompson.
For whatever reason, the Cards do really, really well in the 3-8 range.